Question
Zaid Mohaidd is an Ahl-e-Hadith. He is associated with elderly, prominent scholars and also leads prayers in the Ahl-e-Hadith mosque, but he has adopted the profession of conducting séances. That is, he bathes a child and perfumes him, then recites Ayat al-Kursi and Surah Yaseen, seats the child and places an inscription in his hand, then tells the child to summon the king of the jinn, and accordingly, the king of the jinn appears. The child asks him some questions. Through these séances, he reveals thefts and declares someone a thief. In the same category, he also reveals past events. He also performs talismans, knots, and other such things. He charges one rupee and five annas for the séances; he keeps one rupee himself, gives four annas to the mosque, and five paise to the child. Are such actions permissible according to the Mohaiddin Ahl-e-Hadith? Is it permissible to spend this money on mosque expenses? Is it permissible to pray behind such a person? Rather, Bakr says these actions are acts of shirk (polytheism), so they should be judged by the Quran and Hadith?
Answer
Gentlemen, this practice which Zaid adopts to reveal theft, identify the thief, find treasures, and tell past or future events is absolutely impermissible in the light of the Quran and Hadith. Due to this practice, Zaid is disobedient and sinful, opposing the Quran and Hadith, and deserving of punishment and chastisement.
(1) Because this method is a type of soothsaying. The name refers to telling future events and uncovering hidden matters and claiming knowledge of the unseen. The Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, forbade soothsaying. Hazrat Shah Waliullah Dehlawi writes:
أن النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم نهٰي عن الكهانة وهى الأخبار عن الجن أشد النهي وبرئ ممن أتي كاهنا
وقال الشيخ الدهلوي نقلا عن اللسان والنهاية والكاهن الذى يتعاطي الخبر عن الكائنات فى مستقبل الزمان ويدعي معرفة الاسرار على مواقعها من كلام أو فعل أو حال ويحض باسم العراف وهو الذى يتعاطي مكان المسروق ومكان الضالة ونحوهما وحديث من أتٰي كاهنا يشمل الكاهن والعاف والمنجم قالو او ينبغي للمحتسب منهم و تاديب هم وان يودب الأخذ والمعطي
(2) Because Zaid draws lines and figures on the child’s hand, which is a form of raml (sand divination), and the Prophet, peace be upon him, forbade raml. It is stated:
«العيافة والطيرة والطرق من الجبت الطرق الزجرو العيافة الخط»
(3) Because Zaid asks the king of jinn (Satan) about the unseen, treasures, and theft. This Satan does not have knowledge of the unseen except what Allah has granted to no human or jinn. Even if by eavesdropping he gains some partial knowledge, we are strictly forbidden to trust him. It is stated:
﴿قُل لَّا يَعْلَمُ مَن فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضِ الْغَيْبَ إِلَّا اللَّـهُ ۚ ﴾
(4) Because this practice involves seeking help and assistance from Satan and jinn in matters of needs and repelling harms, which is shirk (polytheism).
(5) Because this practice resembles the methods of the sect of the Pharisees (deviants, apostates deserving death) whose subject is the unseen and its perception, and whose purpose is seeking help and assistance from devils and jinn in needs and repelling harms.
.
(6) Because the Prophet, peace be upon him, did not permit identifying stolen items or lost animals by such special methods and trusting them to accuse someone of theft, nor is this proven or transmitted from the Companions or the Followers. Therefore, it is an innovation and rejected, and the one who commits it is an innovator, misguided, and misguiding.
Allama Nawab Siddiq al-Hasan Kanouji, may Allah have mercy on him, says: Scholars and practitioners of the true Shariah do not approve of this, and its source is other than the clear prophethood of Muhammad. Later, when one of the types of the unseen is established, this kind of knowledge of the unseen is a type of soothsaying, trickery, or magic. There is no doubt that the doer and the one who says this is among the polytheists and those who abandon Islam. The ruling on soothsaying, magic, talismans, and sorcery and what remains of them is explained in the books of religion in their places. There is no need to mention it here from the pure Book and Sunnah. Therefore, there is no doubt that the owner of these acts is undoubtedly misguided and misguiding, and he has blocked the path and his ways are rejected and his indication is false and rejected, and belief according to his knowledge is pure disbelief. The servant is mentioned in Allama Ibn Khaldun where he concludes his speech:
المبسوط علٰي هذهٖ الاعمال بهذا الكلام الجامع وهو قوله ولا سبيل إلٰي معرفة ذلك من هذه الاعمال بل البشر محجوبون عنه وقد استاثر الله تعالىٰ بعلمه والله أعلم وانتم لا تعلمون انتهٰي
(8) Because Zaid tries to practice such knowledge of the unseen and clairvoyance, and all methods of knowledge of the unseen and all types of clairvoyance are misguidance. Nawab Mamduh writes: And in general, whatever it is except prophethood, which is the best way to the knowledge of truth, all types of knowledge of the unseen and clairvoyance are misguidance, whether by means of causes and conditions or by states or by invocations and names or without them. From the pure Shariah, by necessity of transmission and testimony and reason, it is established that knowledge of the unseen from these things is false, and only Allah is the Knower of the unseen. No one can claim it, and if someone claims it, he is against the truth. Whatever is narrated from the unseen that matches reality is not accepted, and no evidence from these sources is free from the judgment of the true Shariah. Therefore, the Muhammadan Shariah has invalidated all of these, and belief in knowledge of the unseen and clairvoyance is a cause of disbelief and kufr and of the type of polytheism and evil because it opposes the oneness of Allah and the confirmation of the Prophethood. Ibn Khaldun said that the knowledge and miracles of the Prophets, peace be upon them, and their news about the unseen universe are divine teachings, and the way for humans to know them is only through them, and these are the true Prophets’ knowledge. As for soothsaying, it is satanic revelation.
(9) Because Zaid misuses Quranic verses and chapters disrespectfully, the Quran was not revealed for these acts. Therefore, Zaid should immediately desist from this un-Islamic practice. Those who go to Zaid for this purpose and trust this practice as correct are greatly sinful. It is stated:
«من أتي كاهناً فصدقه بما يقول فقد برئ بما أنزل على محمد ﷺ» (ابو داؤد)
Money obtained in this way is impermissible to spend on mosque expenses because it is unlawful wealth, and the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, forbade the payment of soothsayers’ fees, as narrated in Tirmidhi and others. Spending unlawful wealth in the mosque is forbidden and impermissible.
«إن اللّٰه طيّب لا يقبل الّا الطيب» (صحيحين)
If this person has the power of leadership (Imamat), he should be removed. It is stated:
اجعلوا ائمتكم خياركم.
The person is cursed whose leadership is disliked by people due to his committing reprehensible acts according to Shariah (Tirmidhi and others). Making amulets and tying knots and blowing on them falls under ﴿وَمِن شَرِّ النَّفَّاثَاتِ فِي الْعُقَدِ﴾. It is regrettable that the superstitions which Ahl al-Hadith used to avoid and which were considered the slogans of innovators are now adopted without hesitation not only by the common people of Ahl al-Hadith but also by some of our scholars. Not only that, but it has become a means of livelihood.