The Tragedy of Modernity, Science, and Behavioral Contradictions
✒ A Reflection on Attitudes and Extremes in the Name of Science
◈ Insistence on Modernity and Science
✔ You advocate for modernity — we accept that.
✔ You believe in science and logic — this too is acknowledged.
✔ You demand proof for everything — a commendable approach.
✔ You find religious discourse and scholars crude or outdated — we accept your perception.
✔ You label others as rigid, ignorant, and irrational — so be it.
◈ But Where Lies the Problem?
① Absence of Solutions
You are quick to point out the flaws in others, yet fail to offer practical solutions yourself.
② Negative Attitudes and Tone
Your tone is often so harsh, sarcastic, and dismissive that people are repelled rather than attracted to what you say.
③ Lack of Knowledge
Despite claiming allegiance to science, you lack basic scientific understanding:
✔ You discuss the theory of evolution without knowing the mechanism of natural selection.
✔ You mention physics and mathematics without comprehending mechanics or L’Hôpital’s Rule.
◈ The Importance of Critique and the Problem of Conduct
You are not fit to be an ambassador of science. By undermining the dignity of the common person, you’ve only made science more inaccessible and intimidating.
Your so-called scientific discussions resemble shaking rocks, cans of ghee, or cow-dung milkshakes — because they are unscientific and devoid of logical argument.
Due to your attitude, the average person is drifting away from both rationality and science.
◈ The Need for Moderation and Balance
✔ Where you’re wrong, you will be opposed.
✔ Where you’re right, you will be supported.
✔ But no claim will be accepted without reason.
◈ The Issue of Extremism
Extremism exists on both ends of the spectrum:
① On one side are those who declare science as disbelief (kufr).
② On the other side are people like you, who adopt unscientific behavior in the name of science.
The truth lies between these extremes. But people like you either sink into the ground or pretend to fly in the skies.
◈ Acknowledgment and Advice
✔ You are neither fit to be a religious scholar nor a scientist.
✔ It would be wise for you to adjust your attitude and relate to the common person.
✔ Avoid expressing opinions in any field without proper knowledge.
