Khulʿ in Islam: Woman’s Right to Divorce with Full Shar’i Guidelines

اردو میں پڑھیں
Font size:
Written by: Sheikh Maqbool Ahmad Salfi Hafizahullah

Nikah is the name of the marriage contract between husband and wife. Whenever the husband needs to separate from the wife due to a Shariah excuse, he can end the marriage contract by giving the wife a divorce, or if the wife needs to obtain separation from the husband due to a Shariah excuse, she can end the marriage contract by exercising the right of Khula. That is, Islam has given each spouse the option to separate on the basis of an excuse. In the following lines, Khula, which is the right of the wife, its procedure, and some of its issues will be explained.

Meaning of Khula:

Husband and wife are like garments for each other, which is why it is called Khula, meaning to remove. In Islamic terminology, Khula means that at the wife’s request, the husband frees his wife from the marriage contract in exchange for compensation. The compensation can be the full dower (mahr) or any amount less than the dower that the husband agrees to, and by presenting it, he frees himself from the marital bond. This is called Khula. Since in Khula separation is obtained from the husband in exchange for compensation, it is also called Fidaa (ransom), and it is referred to as Talaq al-Mal or Talaq al-‘Iwad, which is actually Khula, not Talaq.

Conditions for the validity of Khula:

➊ Khula is the right of the wife, therefore only the wife can demand it; no one else can exercise this right.
➋ For the validity of khula, compensation must exist and be determined, meaning the wife should obtain khula in exchange for the full dower, less than that, or whatever compensation the husband agrees to. Both the existence of compensation and its determination are necessary for khula.
❀ Regarding khula, Allah Almighty says:

فَإِنْ خِفْتُمْ أَلَّا يُقِيمَا حُدُودَ اللَّهِ فَلَا جُنَاحَ عَلَيْهِمَا فِيمَا افْتَدَتْ بِهِ

Reference: (Al-Baqarah: 229)

If you fear that they will not keep within the limits of Allah, then there is no blame on either of them if she gives something for her release.
The evidence from the Sunnah is that it is narrated from Ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both), who said:

أن امرأة ثابت بن قيس أتت النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم، فقالت يا رسول الله، ثابت بن قيس ما أعتب عليه فى خلق ولا دين، ولكني أكره الكفر فى الإسلام، فقال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: أتردين عليه حديقته؟ قالت: نعم، قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: اقبل الحديقة، وطلقها تطليقة

The wife of Thabit bin Qais (may Allah be pleased with him) came to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and said: O Messenger of Allah! I have no complaint against him regarding his character or religion, but I do not like disbelief in Islam (because by staying with him I cannot fulfill the rights of marriage). The Prophet (peace be upon him) asked her: Can you return his garden (which he gave as dower)? She said yes. The Prophet (peace be upon him) said to Thabit (may Allah be pleased with him): Accept your garden and divorce her.

Reference: (Sahih al-Bukhari: 5273)

Here, in the command of Allah and His Messenger (peace be upon him), there is a clear statement about obtaining khula in exchange for compensation. Now, the question arises: if there is no compensation in khula, will it be valid or not? Most scholars say that compensation is necessary for khula; otherwise, khula will not be valid, and this view seems correct. Therefore, when taking khula, the husband should be given something; it is not necessary to give the full dower, a small thing will suffice, and if the husband waives the compensation, khula will still be valid.
However, it is wrong for the husband to demand more than the dower as compensation because in the mentioned incident of Thabit bin Qais (may Allah be pleased with him), the Prophet (peace be upon him) only ordered the return of the dower. In fact, in Sunan Ibn Majah, it is also mentioned that the Prophet (peace be upon him) told him to take back the garden given as dower and forbade excess: The Prophet (peace be upon him) said to Thabit bin Qais:

أن يأخذ منها حديقته ولا يزداد

Translation: To take back his garden from his wife (Jamila, may Allah be pleased with her) and not to take more.

Reference: (Sahih Ibn Majah: 1686)

Thus, in khula, there is a demand from both sides: the wife demands khula, and the husband demands compensation. When both fulfill each other’s demands, khula becomes effective. Sometimes the husband may not demand compensation, yet the wife should offer some compensation so that khula is exchanged for compensation.
❀ For the validity of khula, one condition mentioned is the unity of the session, meaning the offer and acceptance for khula between husband and wife must occur in the same session. The offer is from the husband, and the acceptance is from the wife. For example, if the husband says, “I give you khula for one thousand rupees,” and the wife says, “I accept,” then khula will be valid. But if the offer and acceptance are not in the same session, such as the husband offers in the morning and the wife accepts in another session or later in the evening, khula will not be valid because the wife might withdraw her demand and not accept khula. This issue is agreed upon by the four Imams.

Reference: (See: Al-Mawsu’ah Al-Fiqhiyyah: 209/1)

❀ It is permissible for the husband, wife, or both spouses to appoint a representative for khula. This agency is valid only if the person concerned has genuinely appointed someone as a representative, and scholars have transmitted consensus on the permissibility of agency. (For details, see Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudamah, may Allah have mercy on him.)
❀ Specific words are not necessary for the validity of khula; any phrase indicating divorce, khula, release, or discharge in exchange for compensation will suffice to obtain khula.

Causes of Khula:

Khula is requested by the wife, therefore the wife must have a Shariah-based reason to obtain khula, such as the wife disliking the husband to the extent that there is a risk of falling into ingratitude towards him, as was felt by the wife of Thabit bin Qais رضي الله عنه. We know that ingratitude towards the husband leads to Hell, hence a woman can seek khula from her husband. Similarly, if the husband does not love the wife while the basis of marriage is affection and love, or does not provide maintenance and expenses, or the husband is impotent, or suffers from a dangerous disease, or is abusive and violent, irreligious, ill-mannered, adulterer, or alcoholic, then in such circumstances the wife can obtain khula from her husband.

For khula, having a Shariah-based reason is necessary. If the wife obtains khula without a Shariah-based reason, then the khula will be valid but she will be sinful. Thawban رضي الله عنه says that the Messenger of Allah صلى الله عليه وسلم said:

أيما امرأة سألت زوجها طلاقا فى غير ما بأس، فحرام عليها رائحة الجنة

Whoever woman asks her husband for divorce without any harm that compels her to take divorce, then the fragrance of Paradise is forbidden for her.

Reference: (Sahih Abi Dawood: 2226)

This hadith is about khula because here the wife demands divorce from her husband, therefore Imam Abu Dawood رحمه الله created a chapter on باب فى الخلع based on this hadith. Such a woman is also called a hypocrite in a hadith. It is narrated from Thawban رضي الله عنه that the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said:

المختلعات من المنافقات

Women who take khula without cause are hypocrites.

Reference: (Sahih At-Tirmidhi: 1186)

Method of Khula:

(1) There is no need to go to a ruler, judge, mufti, or scholar for khula; this matter can be settled between husband and wife at home. When the wife sees any Shariah defect in her husband and finds it difficult to live with him, she should demand divorce from her husband. If he willingly gives divorce with the intention of divorce, the woman will be separated from her husband through divorce. But if he does not give divorce, she should seek khula from her husband in exchange for compensation (dower or something mutually agreed upon). The husband should give khula by taking the dower or some compensation (equal to or less than the dower) if his wife does not want to live with him due to a Shariah excuse and demands khula. The form of khula will be that the husband takes the compensation and says to his wife, “I free you or give you khula in exchange for such and such property,” and the wife says, “I accept,” then khula will take place. This matter should happen in one sitting because if offer and acceptance occur in separate gatherings, khula will not take place.

(2) Similarly, the husband can say on the wife’s demand, taking compensation, “I free you,” “I give you divorce,” or “I have taken khula from you,” and khula will take place from all these statements, meaning specific words are not necessary for khula to occur. Any such sentences can be used for khula.

Regarding the khula of Thabit bin Qais (may Allah be pleased with him), three types of women are mentioned. One woman named Jameela bint Abdullah bin Abi Rabi’ah (may Allah be pleased with her), the second named Maryam Maghaliyyah (may Allah be pleased with her), and the third named Habibah bint Sahl (may Allah be pleased with her). These may be three separate incidents, and different forms of expressions for khula are found in the hadiths related to these three types.

One hadith mentions the method of khula where the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) ordered the wife of Thabit (may Allah be pleased with him) to return the garden given as dower and ordered the husband:

اقبل الحديقة، وطلقها تطليقة

“Accept the garden and divorce her.”

Reference: (Sahih al-Bukhari: 5273)

This was the khula.

❀ Another hadith mentions that the Prophet (peace be upon him) ordered the wife to return the garden given as dower and ordered the husband to separate from the wife, so he separated. The words of the hadith are:

فتردين عليه حديقته؟ فقالت: نعم، فردت عليه، وأمره ففارقها

Translation: “Can you return the garden (which she gave as dower)?” She said, “Yes.” So she returned the garden, and by the command of the Prophet (peace be upon him), Thabit (may Allah be pleased with him) separated from her.

Reference: (Sahih al-Bukhari: 5276)

Another hadith mentions separation through khula as follows:

قال: فإني أصدقتها حديقتين، وهما بيدها، فقال النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم: خذهما ففارقها، ففعل

Thabit (may Allah be pleased with him) said, “I gave her two gardens as dower, and they are still with her.” The Prophet (peace be upon him) said, “Take both of them and separate from her.” So he did so.

Reference: (Sahih Abi Dawood: 2228)

❀ Some narrations mention that the Prophet (peace be upon him) caused separation between husband and wife by ordering the return of the dower, similar to separation through a court. For example, in the narration of Ibn Majah:

فقال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: أتردين عليه حديقته؟ قالت: نعم، فردت عليه حديقته، قال: ففرق بينهما رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم

The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said, “Will you return her garden?” She said, “Yes,” and she returned the garden to him, so the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) separated them.

Reference: (Ibn Majah: 2057)

This hadith has been declared weak by Sheikh Albani (may Allah have mercy on him), and in Al-Bayhaqi it is narrated as:

أتردين عليه حديقته؟ قالت: نعم، فأمرها أن ترد عليه ففرق بينهما

Translation: “Will you return her garden?” The wife said, “Yes.” So the Prophet (peace be upon him) ordered the woman to return it to Thabit (may Allah be pleased with him) and separated them.

Reference: (Al-Sunan al-Kubra by Al-Bayhaqi: 14840)

❀ Some narrations mention that for khula, the husband should take what was given and leave the wife’s path. See the narration in Sunan an-Nasa’i, when Jameela bint Abdullah bin Abi Rabi’ah (may Allah be pleased with her) came complaining about her husband, the Prophet (peace be upon him) said to Thabit (may Allah be pleased with him):

خذ الذى لها عليك، وخل سبيلها، قال: نعم، فأمرها رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم أن تتربص حيضة واحدة، فتلحق بأهلها

Translation: “Take what you gave her and leave her path.” He said, “Okay.” Then the Prophet (peace be upon him) ordered her (Jameela, may Allah be pleased with her) to complete one menstrual cycle of waiting (‘iddah) and then go to her family.

Reference: (Sahih an-Nasa’i: 3497)

From this hadith, it is understood that the woman can complete the khula waiting period of one menstrual cycle at her husband’s house and then go to her parental home, but it is not necessary; she can also complete the waiting period at her own home.

In any case, to give khula, the husband can take compensation and say any words indicating freedom to the wife, and khula will take place, as I have tried to prove by collecting various hadiths. When khula is done by mutual consent at home, it is better to have two just witnesses because sometimes disputes arise in this matter. However, khula will take place even without witnesses, and if khula is recorded in writing on paper, it is even better so that the evidence and proof remain preserved in writing, but khula will also take place verbally.

(3) When the husband is neither willing to give divorce nor khula, the wife faces a problem. There is a solution for this as well. In such a case, the wife should file a khula case in a Shariah court and obtain khula through the court. The court should summon both husband and wife and first try reconciliation, and if reconciliation is not possible and there is a valid reason for separation between the spouses, the court should ask the husband to give divorce. If he is not willing to give divorce, the court should grant khula in exchange for compensation. If the husband neither gives divorce nor agrees to khula and does not appear in court, what should the court do? The court should make every possible effort to notify the husband and give him adequate time to appear in court, even informing him multiple times so that later he has no excuse to blame the wife or the court. If after repeated notifications and granting time, the husband does not appear in court while the wife has a valid Shariah excuse for separation, the court should annul the marriage without the husband’s presence and consent so that the wife becomes free from that man.

(4) In many places, there is no Shariah court or Dar al-Qada (court of justice), so in such places, do not take the khula case to a non-Shariah court or to a non-Muslim because such a court will decide according to the democratic constitution and will have no connection with Islamic Shariah.

The question arises: then where should a woman go for khula? Such a woman should call a panchayat (council) with the help of a reliable scholar involving both parties, or if there is a reliable educational institution or religious center nearby, she should get khula done through its responsible persons. This panchayat or institution should carry out the khula process like a court proceeding, i.e., in the first stage, try to get the husband to attend the gathering and attempt reconciliation, divorce, or khula, whichever is possible. If the husband does not attend the gathering despite notification and efforts, annul the marriage without his consent, so the woman’s marriage will be annulled.

The summary of all these points is that when a woman does not want to live with her husband due to a Shariah excuse, there are two ways to obtain separation: one is divorce, which is the husband’s right, meaning she becomes free by taking divorce from the husband; the second is khula, which is the woman’s right, meaning she gives compensation to the husband and obtains khula or annuls her marriage through court or panchayat and becomes free from the husband.

Is Khula Divorce or Annulment?

Among scholars, there is a difference of opinion on whether Khula is divorce or annulment of marriage. The prevailing and stronger view in this matter is that Khula is annulment of marriage. The evidence for this is that Allah Almighty mentioned two divorces in verse 129 of Surah Al-Baqarah, then mentioned Khula, and then in the next verse mentioned the third divorce. If Khula were considered divorce, then the mention of the third divorce would have to be considered the fourth divorce, but no one accepts a fourth divorce. Therefore, Khula is not divorce; it is annulment, and for this reason, there are many differences between divorce and Khula, for example, the waiting period (iddah) for divorce is three menstrual cycles, while for Khula it is one menstrual cycle, and there is reconciliation (ruju’) in the first and second divorce but no reconciliation in Khula.

Waiting Period (Iddah) of Khula:

❀ Whether khula is agreed upon between husband and wife at home or khula or annulment of marriage is done through court or panchayat, in all these cases the woman’s iddah will be one menstrual cycle. After khula, one menstrual cycle should come and the woman should become pure from it, then the iddah is completed. Rabi’ bint Mu’adh bin Afra’ رضي الله عنها says:

أنها اختلعت على عهد النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم فأمرها النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم، أو أمرت أن تعتد بحيضة

Translation: They took khula during the time of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, and he ﷺ ordered them (or they were ordered) to observe one menstrual cycle as iddah.

Reference: (Sahih al-Tirmidhi: 1185)

Similarly, in a suspended narration of Abu Dawood:

عن ابن عمر قال: عدة المختلعة حيضة

Translation: It is narrated from Abdullah bin Umar رضي الله عنهما that the iddah of a woman who has taken khula is one menstrual cycle.

Reference: (Sahih Abi Dawood: 2230)

Sheikh al-Albani رحمه الله said that this narration is suspended but authentic.
Those who have counted khula as divorce and said that the iddah is three menstrual cycles, this is not correct. Khula is neither divorce nor does it require three menstrual cycles of iddah. The woman who has taken khula should observe one menstrual cycle as iddah. The wisdom behind three menstrual cycles in divorce is that during the long waiting period the husband may reconcile, whereas in khula there is no reconciliation; one menstrual cycle is only for the purification of the womb.
Khula can happen during menstruation, pregnancy, or purity after intercourse, and if khula occurs during menstruation, that menstruation will not be counted but the next menstruation will be counted as iddah. If khula occurs during pregnancy, then the delivery will be the iddah. It is not necessary to observe the iddah of khula in the former husband’s house; she can observe iddah anywhere, even in the husband’s house. However, since khula establishes separation between the two, privacy should be avoided and the woman should observe hijab from the former husband. If a pregnant woman takes khula, the husband must arrange both accommodation and maintenance for her until delivery. The woman who has taken khula should reside in her own home during iddah and should not go out unnecessarily, but if there is a necessity, she may go out.

Reconciliation and Marriage after Khula:

Through khula, separation between husband and wife is achieved; this is a minor irrevocable separation (binunah sughra). This means that the husband cannot reconcile with the woman who has obtained khula, but if the husband wishes to choose the same wife again, he can do so by marrying her anew with a new dowry after the completion of the iddah period of khula. Just as after the completion of the iddah period of the first or second divorce, if the husband wishes to take back his former wife, he can do so through a new marriage and a new dowry. There is a major irrevocable separation (binunah kubra) which occurs after the third divorce; in this case, there is neither reconciliation nor can the husband and wife marry each other again unless she marries another man and he divorces her.

Ruling on Delegated Divorce:

It is generally observed that when a husband wants to leave his wife, he divorces her and separates from her. However, when a woman wants to obtain separation from her husband on a legitimate Islamic excuse, the husband troubles her, neither allowing her to live peacefully in the house, nor giving her a divorce, nor agreeing to grant her khula (divorce initiated by the wife). Considering such situations, a new custom has emerged in society, which is called delegated divorce (Talaq Tafweez). Delegated divorce means that at the time of marriage, the man delegates the right of divorce to his wife, so that just as the husband can divorce the wife, the wife can also divorce the husband. In other words, by using this delegated divorce, the woman can divorce her husband whenever she wishes and become free from him. In reality, this delegated divorce is a new innovation in religion; it will have no validity because giving divorce is solely the right of the man, and obtaining khula is the right of the woman. Therefore, Muslims should not adopt the arbitrary method of delegated divorce, and if by mistake or force a woman has been given delegated divorce, it will have no validity, nor will the woman’s divorce lead to separation from the husband.

Hanafis and Khula:

Since the majority of our society belongs to the Hanafi school and there are many baseless issues regarding khula among them, it is necessary for them to know the following:

(1) The Hanafis consider khula as divorce, whereas the correct view is that khula is not divorce but the annulment of marriage (fasakh nikah). Therefore, the ruling of divorce will not apply to a woman who has obtained khula; instead, the ruling of annulment of marriage will apply.

(2) The Hanafis consider the waiting period (iddah) for khula to be three menstrual cycles, whereas the correct view is that the iddah for khula is one menstrual cycle, the evidence for which has already been presented.

(3) The Hanafis do not accept khula without the husband’s consent, whether the khula is granted by the court or by the panchayat (local council). However, the correct position is that, considering the circumstances and conditions, khula or annulment of marriage can occur even without the husband’s consent because sometimes the husband oppresses his wife so much that loving him and fulfilling the rights of marriage is out of the question; he does not even provide for her financially, meaning he does not care for her in the slightest. In such a situation, he neither gives divorce nor agrees to khula. In such cases, the wife can seek the help of the court or panchayat and annul the marriage without the husband’s consent and free herself from this oppressive man.

Summary of Discussions:

At the end of this discussion, I will mention some important and key points regarding Khula so that the summary and the main purpose of the article remain clear.
❀ Khula means the husband taking compensation and separating from the wife.
❀ Khula is the right of the wife; when the wife has a Shariah-based need to separate from the husband, she can separate from her husband through Khula by giving compensation.
❀ In exchange for compensation, the husband’s freeing of his wife through words like divorce, Khula, annulment, separation, or freedom will be considered Khula.
❀ The woman should demand Khula only when it becomes difficult to live with the husband due to a Shariah excuse, but she should not seek Khula due to minor discomfort or minor difficulties; rather, she should live with patience with the same husband because life is a combination of both happiness and sorrow, and there is no husband in the world who only provides comfort without any hardship.
❀ Essentially, Khula will be conducted with the mutual consent of husband and wife, but in unavoidable circumstances when separation is permissible for the wife and the husband does not grant separation through divorce or Khula, then after complete investigation and informing the husband, the marriage can be annulled without the husband’s consent through court or Panchayat.
❀ After Khula, the woman must observe her ‘iddah’ in her own home because the marital relationship has ended and there is no possibility of reconciliation; however, she can also observe ‘iddah’ in the husband’s house. The ‘iddah’ of Khula is one menstrual cycle; once the woman experiences one menstrual cycle after Khula and becomes pure, her ‘iddah’ is complete.
❀ There is no reconciliation during the ‘iddah’ of Khula, but if the husband and wife want to reunite, they can do so after the ‘iddah’ with a new marriage contract and new dowry. It should be clear that this marriage will be conducted Shariah-wise just like the first time because it is a permanent marriage, requiring a guardian, dowry, two just witnesses, and the announcement of marriage.
❀ If someone has given his wife two divorces previously and then Khula occurs, in this case also, after the completion of Khula’s ‘iddah’, marriage can take place because Khula is not divorce; it is merely separation and annulment of marriage.
❀ During the ‘iddah’ of Khula, the husband is not obligated to provide maintenance or residence, but if the woman is pregnant, then maintenance and residence must be provided until delivery.
❀ Divorce by delegation is a new innovation and a kind of bid’ah which should be eliminated from Muslim society, and praise be to Allah, under Shariah excuse, the woman has full right to obtain freedom from the husband; therefore, there is no need for any self-invented method, and in fact, we do not have permission for it.