Qatadah narrates: This same report has reached us from the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). This is the authentic version from Qatadah; Ma'mar, Abu Awanah, Sa'id bin Abu Arubah and Sa'id bin Bashir agreed on it, narrating it from Qatadah, from Abu al-Aliyah, and Salm bin Abu al-Dhayyal followed them in it from Qatadah and narrated it as mursal. So these are five reliable narrators who narrated it from Qatadah, from Abu al-Aliyah, as a mursal report. Whereas Ayyub bin Khawt, Dawud bin al-Muhabbar, Abdul Rahman bin Amr bin Jabalah and Hasan bin Dinar are all abandoned (matruk); there is none among them whose narration could be used as evidence even if no one contradicted him, so how can it be when each one of them has contradicted five reliable students of Qatadah? As for the report of Hasan bin Dinar from Hasan, from Abu al-Malih, from his father, it is also far from correct, and we do not know of anyone who followed him in it. Abdul Karim Abu Umayyah narrated it from Hasan, from Sayyiduna Abu Hurairah (may Allah be pleased with him); Abdul Karim is abandoned, and the one who narrates it from him is Abdul Aziz bin al-Husayn, who is also weak. Umar bin Qays al-Makki, known as Sandal, who is weak and whose hadith is discarded, narrated it from Amr bin Ubayd, from Hasan, from Sayyiduna Imran bin Husain (may Allah be pleased with him), from the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). As for the report of Abdul Karim, it is as follows.
Hadith Referenceسنن الدارقطني / كتاب الطهارة / 610
Hadith Takhrij«أخرجه الدارقطني فى ((سننه)) برقم: 610، انفرد به المصنف من هذا الطريق»