A man saying to another: May Allah keep you alive: those who disliked it until he says: with peace

Asim and Hammad said, respectively, that Ibn Sirin and Ibrahim both said: "When you say 'Hayyaka Allah' (May Allah keep you alive), then give the greeting of peace along with it."

Something similar is reported from Ibrahim through Abu Ma'shar.

And Hammad reported from Ibrahim; both of them (Ibn Sirin and Ibrahim) said: "When you say 'Hayyaka Allah' (May Allah keep you alive), then say: 'bi-s-salam' (with peace)."

Abd al-Majid said that al-Hasan al-Basri considered it disliked for a man to say 'Hayyaka Allah' unless he also says the greeting of peace.

Muhammad bin Suqah said: Maymun bin Mihran came to us, and a man said to him: 'Hayyaka Allah' (May Allah keep you alive). He said: "Do not say it like that. This is the greeting of young men. Rather say: 'Hayyakumu Allahu bi-s-salam' (May Allah keep you alive with peace)."

Al-A'mash said that Ibrahim said: "They used to like it that when a man says to another man 'Hayyaka Allah', he also says the greeting of peace along with it."