Those Who Say There Is a Penalty for Pointing Out Game to a Hunter

Hasan and Hazrat Ata say that if a Muhrim gestures towards the game and another Muhrim hunts it, then the one who made the gesture is also liable for compensation.

Hazrat Saeed bin Jubair states that the one who signals, the one who guides, and the one who strikes—each of them will receive their recompense.

A man came to Hazrat Ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them) and said, "While in the state of Ihram, I pointed towards a deer and it was hunted." He replied, "You are also liable."

A man said to Hazrat Tawus, "While in the state of Ihram, I gestured towards hunting for a person who was not in Ihram." He replied, "You are also liable."

Hazrat Ibn Umar (may Allah be pleased with both of them) narrates that a Muhrim should neither point towards game nor indicate it.

It is narrated in the same manner from Hazrat Tawus.

Hazrat Sha'bi says that if a Muhrim points towards the game and it is hunted, then expiation is also obligatory upon that Muhrim.

Hazrat Ata, Hazrat Tawus, and Hazrat Mujahid state that if a Muhrim (a person in the state of Ihram) orders a non-Muhrim (a person not in Ihram) to hunt, then expiation (kaffarah) is also obligatory upon him.