People in ihram who share in hunting game

Ibrahim said: A single compensation (jaza') is due from all of them.

Al-Sha'bi said the same.

Al-Hakam said: If they all took part in killing that game and his companions did not pay the ransom (fidyah), then the whole ransom is due from that one person.

Ata, Tawus and Mujahid said: In this case a single compensation (jaza') is due from all of them.

And Mujahid said: If they all ate from it, then a separate compensation (jaza') is due from each one of them.

Sa'id said: A separate compensation (jaza') is due from each one.

Al-Sha'bi said the same.

Al-Sha'bi said: If they all took part in the hunt, a compensation (jaza') is due from each one.

Ata said: If they ate from it, then a compensation (jaza') is due from each one; and if they did not eat from it, then a single compensation is due from the two of them.

Hajjaj said: I asked Abu Ja'far and Ata about some people in ihram who hunt game together. They said: "A single compensation (jaza') is due from all of them."

Ata said: If two men hunt some game together, a single expiation (kaffarah) is due from them; and if they eat from it, then a separate expiation is due from each of them.

Al-Hasan said: An expiation is due from each person among them.

Sayyiduna Ibn Umar (may Allah be pleased with them both) was asked about a group of people travelling on foot who killed some game. He said: "A single compensation (jaza') is due from all of them."

Al-Zuhri said: If two men hunt some game together, a single compensation (jaza') is due from the two of them.

Al-Sha'bi said: A separate compensation (jaza') is due from each one.

And Hammad said: A single compensation (jaza') suffices on behalf of both of them.

The narrator said: I mentioned al-Sha'bi's view to al-Harith, and he said: "The correct view is what Hammad said."