The Ahl al-Ḥadīth have always adhered to one fundamental principle: for any incident or narration to be accepted, the authenticity and reliability of its chain of transmission (sanad) is an essential condition. It is this very principle that has preserved the science of ḥadīth from distortion and fabricated tales.
In light of this principle, the famous story regarding fragrance emanating from the grave of Imām al-Muḥaddithīn, Ḥāfiẓ al-Dunyā Muḥammad ibn Ismāʿīl al-Bukhārī رحمه الله, is also examined. This incident is mentioned in biographical works and is often narrated in public gatherings. However, when its chain of transmission is scrutinized, it is not established.
In this article, we will first present the original chain of the incident and the opinions of the scholars regarding it. Thereafter, we will examine the objections raised by the “Barelwī scholars” one by one and provide detailed responses to their arguments. Thus, it will become completely clear to the reader that this story is weak and unreliable, and that the stance of Ahl al-Ḥadīth is firmly rooted in principles and scholarship.
Analysis of the Incident and Its Chain of Transmission
The story of fragrance emanating from the grave of Imām al-Bukhārī رحمه الله was first mentioned by Imām al-Dhahabī رحمه الله in his renowned book:
📘 Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalā’ (12/467)
There, Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq narrated from Abū Manṣūr Ghālib ibn Jibrīl that when Imām al-Bukhārī رحمه الله was buried, a fragrance more pleasant and delicate than musk began emanating from the soil of his grave. This condition reportedly remained for several days. People came from far and wide to collect soil, until a wooden enclosure had to be placed around the grave to protect it.
This story is also found in other works, such as:
📕 Taghlīq al-Taʿlīq (5/141)
📕 Ṭabaqāt al-Subkī (2/233)
📕 Muqaddimah Fatḥ al-Bārī (p. 493)
📕 Al-Wāfī bi al-Wafayāt (2/208)
However, in terms of the chain of transmission, this incident is not established.
Examination of the Narrators
① Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq
He remained close to Imām al-Bukhārī and narrated aspects of his life. However, none of the ḥadīth scholars explicitly declared him trustworthy (thiqah, i.e. possessing integrity and precision). In the books of al-jarḥ wa al-taʿdīl, no reliable authentication is found for him. Therefore, he is considered majhūl al-ḥāl (unknown in reliability).
② Ghālib ibn Jibrīl
He is the principal witness of this incident. Yet, no reliable authentication from any recognized ḥadīth scholar exists for him either. Imām al-Khaṭīb al-Baghdādī merely stated that he was counted among the people of knowledge, but that he had no musnad ḥadīth.
📘 Al-Muttafiq wa al-Muftariq
This casts doubt upon his scholarly standing.
③ Disconnection and Obscurity in the Chain
The contemporary ḥadīth scholar, Ḥāfiẓ Zubayr ʿAlī Za’ī رحمه الله, explicitly stated that even the chain from Imām al-Dhahabī to Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim is unknown.
📘 Maqālāt (3/580)
Principled Point
The principle of Ahl al-Ḥadīth is that whether a narration concerns virtue or a great Imām, if its chain is not authentic, it will be rejected. The status and greatness of Imām al-Bukhārī رحمه الله are unquestionably established, but fabricating or spreading unverified tales about him is not correct.
Objections of the Barelwī Scholars and Their Responses
Objection 1
They argue:
“Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq was not unknown. He remained with Imām al-Bukhārī, much of his biography is narrated from him, and scholars accepted his narrations. Therefore, the objection that he is unknown is not correct.”
Response
This objection is contrary to the principles of ḥadīth, for the following reasons:
➊ Definition of Majhūl
According to the ḥadīth scholars, a narrator is considered majhūl when his integrity and precision are not established by reliable critics.
Ḥāfiẓ Ibn Ḥajar رحمه الله said:
إذ المجهول غير محتج به
“Indeed, a majhūl narrator is not used as proof.”
📘
➋ Mere Companionship Does Not Establish Reliability
Simply being close to Imām al-Bukhārī does not remove the ruling of being majhūl. Scholars have always required explicit authentication for accepting a narration. Mere association or proximity has never been sufficient proof.
➌ Transmission by Scholars ≠ Authentication
When ḥadīth scholars transmitted a narration with its chain, they absolved themselves of responsibility.
Ḥāfiẓ Ibn Ḥajar رحمه الله clarified:
بل أكثر المحدثين … إذا ساقوا الحديث بإسناده اعتقدوا أنهم برؤوا من عهدته
📘
Meaning: When scholars mentioned a narration with its chain, they considered themselves free of responsibility, even if a narrator within it was majhūl.
➍ That 80 Percent of the Merits Are Narrated from Him
It is true that much of Imām al-Bukhārī’s biography is narrated through al-Warrāq. However, since he is majhūl al-ḥāl, most of his narrations cannot be used as proof. The greatness of Imām al-Bukhārī does not depend upon narrations from an unknown narrator.
📍 Conclusion
No reliable Imām explicitly authenticated Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq. Therefore, he is majhūl, and reliance upon his narration is not permissible.
Objection 2
They argue:
“Ḥāfiẓ Ibn Ḥajar al-ʿAsqalānī رحمه الله mentioned, with his own chain, a connection up to Imām Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq. Hence this narrator is reliable and his narration can be relied upon.”
Response
➊ Presence of Multiple Unknown Narrators
In Taghlīq al-Taʿlīq ʿalā Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, the chain mentioned by Ibn Ḥajar contains more than five narrators whose reliability is not established.
Ḥāfiẓ Ibn Ḥajar رحمه الله himself stated:
إذ المجهول غير محتج به
📘
“Indeed, a majhūl narrator is not used as proof.”
Ḥāfiẓ Ibn Ḥajar رحمه الله himself is stating the principle that a narrator whose condition is unknown, his narration is unreliable. Thus, the mere existence of a chain is not proof of authentication.
➋ Statement of Imām al-Bayhaqī رحمه الله
فِيهِ دَلَالَةٌ عَلَى أَنَّهُ لَا يَجُوزُ قَبُولُ خَبَرِ الْمَجْهُولِينَ حَتَّى يُعْلَمَ مِنْ أَحْوَالِهِمْ مَا يُوجِبُ قَبُولَ أَخْبَارِهِمْ
📘
“It indicates that the report of unknown narrators cannot be accepted until their conditions are known in a manner that justifies accepting their reports.”
According to this principle of al-Bayhaqī رحمه الله, as long as there is no explicit testimony to a narrator’s integrity and precision, his narration will be rejected. Hence, when the chain of Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq contains unknown narrators, it is not reliable.
Objection 3
They argue:
“Imām al-Dhahabī رحمه الله also mentioned Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq with his own chain; therefore, he is reliable.”
Response
➊ Unknown Narrators in al-Dhahabī’s Chain
The chain of Imām al-Dhahabī رحمه الله mentioned in Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalā’ also contains several narrators of unknown condition (majhūl al-ḥāl). No reliable Imām has explicitly declared them trustworthy.
➋ The Narration of Unknown Narrators Is Not Reliable
The Imams of uṣūl have stated explicitly that the narration of a majhūl or mastūr narrator is not proof:
Imām Ḥusām al-Dīn al-Akhsīkathī (d. 644 AH, Ḥanafī):
“Like the ḥadīth of a fāsiq, the ḥadīth of a mastūr (i.e. one of unknown condition) is also not proof until his integrity becomes apparent.”
Explanation: That is, an unknown narrator cannot be regarded as reliable until testimony to his trustworthiness is found.
Imām Ibn al-Humām (Ḥanafī):
المجهول الحال راوي مستور، وروايته عند أبي حنيفة غير مقبولة
“A narrator of unknown condition is considered mastūr, and his narration is not accepted according to Imām Abū Ḥanīfah رحمه الله.”
Explanation: Here it is explicit that, even according to the principles of Ḥanafī fiqh, the narration of an unknown narrator is not proof.
📍 Summary
Neither the chain of Ḥāfiẓ Ibn Ḥajar رحمه الله nor the chain of Imām al-Dhahabī رحمه الله can remove the status of Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq as majhūl, because both contain unknown narrators. And in principle, the narration of a majhūl narrator is not proof.
Objection 4
They argue:
“Ghālib ibn Jibrīl was counted among the people of knowledge; Imām al-Khaṭīb al-Baghdādī has reported that he was among the people of knowledge. Therefore, the incident of fragrance from the grave of Imām al-Bukhārī رحمه الله cannot be denied.”
Response
➊ The Statement of al-Khaṭīb al-Baghdādī
Imām al-Khaṭīb al-Baghdādī رحمه الله said:
لا أعلم له حديثا مسندا، يقال إنه كان من أهل العلم
📘
“I do not know of any musnad narration from Ghālib ibn Jibrīl; it is said that he was among the people of knowledge.”
This clearly shows that although he was regarded as knowledgeable, he had no musnad narrations. That is, he was not a ḥadīth scholar or a trustworthy (thiqah) narrator, but merely an ordinary man of knowledge. A report narrated from such a person cannot be made a proof.
➋ Principle of Imām Mālik رحمه الله
لَا يُؤْخَذُ الْعِلْمُ مِنْ أَرْبَعَةٍ … وَلَا مِنْ شَيْخٍ لَهُ فَضْلٌ وَصَلَاحٌ وَعِبَادَةٌ إِذَا كَانَ لَا يَعْرِفُ مَا يُحَدِّثُ
📘
“Knowledge is not taken from four types of people… including a pious and righteous worshipper who does not know what he narrates.”
Explanation: The condition of Ghālib ibn Jibrīl is the same. Even if he was counted among the people of knowledge, since he had no knowledge of narration and ḥadīth, a report narrated from him cannot be relied upon.
➌ The Verdict of the Ḥadīth Scholars Regarding Unknown Narrators
◈ Ḥāfiẓ Ibn Ḥajar رحمه الله:
إذ المجهول غير محتج به
“A majhūl narrator is not used as proof.”
📘
◈ Imām al-Bayhaqī رحمه الله:
لا يجوز قبول خبر المجهولين حتى يعلم من أحوالهم ما يوجب قبول أخبارهم.
“The report of unknown narrators cannot be accepted until their integrity is established.”
📘
◈ Imām Ḥusām al-Dīn al-Akhsīkathī (Ḥanafī):
“Like the fāsiq, the ḥadīth of a mastūr is also not proof until his integrity becomes apparent.”
◈ Imām Ibn al-Humām (Ḥanafī):
“A narrator of unknown condition is mastūr, and his narration is not accepted according to Imām Abū Ḥanīfah.”
Summary and Final Conclusion
① Muḥammad ibn Abī Ḥātim al-Warrāq has not been explicitly authenticated by any reliable Imām; therefore, he is majhūl.
② Ghālib ibn Jibrīl is also not an established narrator; he was merely described as being among the people of knowledge, with no musnad narrations known from him.
③ The report of an unknown or unreliable narrator cannot be used as proof in religion, no matter how famous it may be.
④ The greatness of Imām al-Bukhārī رحمه الله is not dependent upon such unverified stories. His greatest karāmah (honour) is his book Al-Jāmiʿ al-Ṣaḥīḥ, which has been regarded as the most authentic book after the Qur’ān.
🔴 Final Verdict
The story that fragrance emanated from the grave of Imām al-Bukhārī رحمه الله is not authentically established through a sound chain of transmission. It is not valid as proof because its primary narrators are unknown. Therefore, according to the principles of Ahl al-Ḥadīth, this incident is either false or at the very least unreliable, and no religious argument can be based upon it.









