Reasons for Insulting Behavior in Atheists’ Debates
When an atheist objects to Islam or debates with a Muslim, it is generally observed that he uses insulting and hateful language about Islamic sacred things. The question arises: why does he do so? The reasons may be as follows:
- A state of reaction: Sometimes an atheist uses insulting language because of a Muslim’s behavior or emotional reaction. Although this behavior is wrong, it may be understandable to some extent.
- Lack of argument: Some atheists do not have strong arguments with which to object to Islam, so they resort to insulting sacred things.
- An attempt to cause hurt: Under the pressure of defeat or nerves in a debate, they use insulting language to inflict mental pain on the other person.
The Arguments of Atheists and Their Confusions
Atheists present various arguments in favor of their insulting language:
- Everyone has the freedom to say whatever he wishes.
- If something is wrong, prove it wrong with arguments.
- They have just as much freedom as Muslims have.
These arguments have two fundamental flaws:
- Failing to understand the difference between an argument and an insult: The perfection of human consciousness is that it tries to understand a matter through logic and argument, whereas in an insult this logic comes to an end.
- The importance of the centers of love and respect: For a person, respect for his relationships, his ties, and his centers of love (such as religion and family) is important. By insulting these centers, that person is made to suffer mental pain.
The Negative Effects of Insulting
- Insulting goes outside the scope of debate on rational grounds.
- An insult, whether true or false, causes pain to the other person.
- The person who insults ignores both the emotional and the logical aspects.
- This behavior takes a person to a depravity of consciousness, where intellect and human feelings have no value left.
Example: Insulting One’s Mother
If one wants to object to the character of someone’s mother, it can be proven through arguments, for example:
- She was seen doing such-and-such an act at such-and-such a time and place.
- Evidence and witnesses should be presented.
- Pictures or videos should be shown.
For this there is no need to use the word “prostitute” or any other insulting word. But if an insult is hurled, then:
- The one who hears the insult will feel pain.
- In anger he will insult in return or resort to violence.
- The purpose of the debate, that is, making the truth clear, gets lost somewhere.
An Analysis of the Behavior of Atheists
An atheist who uses insulting language about religious figures or sacred things has in fact become devoid of two things:
- The ability to give a rational argument: Instead of proving his point with arguments, he resorts to insults and abuse.
- Regard for human feelings: He takes no account of the feelings of the other person.
This behavior amounts to abandoning the loftiness of humanity and descending to a bestial and satanic level, where ridicule, mockery, and inflicting pain reflect his mentality.
Types of Atheists
- The logical atheist: These people speak only on the basis of arguments and never adopt an insulting attitude. They are generally not preachers of atheism either, and are prone to doubts and misgivings. Debate with them is possible, and they maintain a civilized attitude.
- The partially insulting atheist: These atheists speak logically at first, but when they face defeat they adopt an insulting attitude. This article partly sheds light on them as well.
- The purely insulting atheist: Instead of giving rational arguments against Islam, these people resort to insults and abuse. The only purpose of their opposition is to cause Muslims pain. This article has been written mainly to examine the behavior of these very people.
Advice for Muslims
- Stay in the rational and moral field: Bring the atheist onto your own ground, that is, morality and logic.
- Avoid insults: Refrain from responding to the atheist’s insulting behavior in the same manner.
- Stay away from satanic behavior: If the atheist remains immersed in his base emotions, leave him and protect yourself from harm.
Guidance of the Noble Quran
It has been said in the Noble Quran:
“وَ اِذَا رَاَیۡتَ الَّذِیۡنَ یَخُوۡضُوۡنَ فِیۡۤ اٰیٰتِنَا فَاَعۡرِضۡ عَنۡہُمۡ حَتّٰی یَخُوۡضُوۡا فِیۡ حَدِیۡثٍ غَیۡرِہٖ…”
That is, when people mock the verses of Allah, keep away from them.
Similarly, it has been said:
“وَلَا تَكُونُوا كَالَّذِينَ نَسُوا اللَّهَ فَأَنسَاهُمْ أَنفُسَهُمْ…”
That is, those who forget Allah forget themselves as well.
Conclusion
The insulting language of atheists is in fact an expression of their rational and emotional defeat. A Muslim should not answer such behavior with insults, but should make clear the truth of Islam through his good character and his argument.