The Shari’ah Status of Dua after Funeral Prayer

اردو میں پڑھیں
Font size:
Written by: Ghulam Mustafa Zaheer Amanpuri

Immediately after the funeral prayer, collectively raising the hands and making a du’a for the deceased is an abominable innovation (bid’ah qabihah). There is no basis for it in the Quran and Hadith, and it has not been reported from the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, the Rightly Guided Caliphs, the Companions, the great Tabi’in, the Imams of the religion, or the pious predecessors (salaf salihin).

Despite this, the “Qabri sect” considers it permissible. If collective du’a with raised hands immediately after the funeral prayer were permissible, the Companions, who were the most knowledgeable of all people in understanding the meanings, implications and requirements of the Quran and Hadith, and who shaped their lives in accordance with them, would certainly have done it.
Neither the permissibility nor the recommendation of this practice has been reported from the four Imams either.
◈ The Barelwi leader, Mr. Ahmad Yar Khan Naeemi, writes:
“In matters of Shariah we consider the saying and action of Imam Sahib (Abu Hanifah) as our evidence, and we do not look at the Shariah evidences.”

Reference: Jaa al-Haq 15/1

◈ Also, regarding a certain issue, he writes:
“The evidence of the Hanafis is not these narrations; their evidence is only the saying of the Imam.”

Reference: Jaa al-Haq 104, 9/6

↰ Now it is incumbent upon the innovators to prove from their Imam Abu Hanifah, with a “Sahih” chain, the recommendation of this practice; otherwise they will have to accept that this sect has no connection with Imam Abu Hanifah. And those who write books under the name أجلي الآ علام بأن الفتوٰي مطلقا على قول قول الامام should be ashamed when presenting references such as “Kashf al-Ghita” and others!

↰ It should be noted that some Hanafi Imams have also prohibited making du’a immediately after the funeral prayer and have declared it disliked:
➊ Ibn Nujaym al-Hanafi, whom the Hanafis remember as Abu Hanifah the Second, writes:

ولا يدعو بعد التسليم

“One should not make du’a after the salam of the funeral prayer.”

Reference: al-Bahr al-Ra’iq li-Ibn Nujaym al-Hanafi: 183/7

➋ Tahir ibn Ahmad al-Hanafi al-Bukhari (d. 542 AH) writes:

لايقوم بالد عاء فى قرائة القرآن لأ جل الميت بعد صلاة الجنازة وقبلها لا يقوم بالدعاء بعد صلاة الجنازة

“One should not stop before or after the funeral prayer to recite the Quran for the deceased, nor should one stop for the purpose of du’a immediately after the funeral prayer.”

Reference: Khulasat al-Fatawa: 225/1

➌ Ibrahim ibn Abd al-Rahman al-Karki (835-922 AH), a student of Ibn al-Humam al-Hanafi, writes:

والدّعاء بعد صلاة الجنازة مروه كما يفعله العوّ ا م فى قرأء ة الفاتحة بعد الصّلاة عليه قبل أن تر فع

“Reciting Surah al-Fatihah for the purpose of du’a after the funeral prayer and before lifting the deceased, as the common people do, is disliked.”

Reference: Fatawa Faid Karki: 88

➍ Muhammad Khurasani al-Hanafi (d. 926 AH) writes:

ولا يقوم داعيا له

“One should not stand for the du’a for the deceased after (immediately following) the funeral prayer.”

Reference: Jami’ al-Rumuz: 125/1

Objection: These statements show that immediately after the funeral prayer one should make du’a while seated, not standing; they do not negate du’a altogether.

Reply:
This meaning is false for several reasons:
➊ This meaning is not mentioned in any reliable Hanafi book, so it is rejected as baseless.
➋ Here “qiyam” does not mean standing up, but rather stopping/remaining. As the statement of Allah the Exalted shows: وَلَا تَقُمْ عَلَى قَبْرِهِ

Reference: 9-al-Tawbah:84

meaning: “Do not stop at the grave of any of them (the hypocrites).” It does not mean that one cannot stand at the graves of the hypocrites but may make du’a while seated; rather, “qiyam” here means stopping, i.e., you may not stop at their graves for du’a.

Let us now examine the alleged evidences for du’a immediately after the funeral prayer:

Evidence No. ➊

Allah the Exalted says:

أُجِيبُ دَعْوَةَ الدَّاعِ إِذَا دَعَانِ

“I answer the supplication of the supplicant when he calls upon Me.”

Comment:
① Presenting this as proof of the practice through general evidences is not correct.
② The Prophet ﷺ and the Companions, who knew the meanings and implications of the Quran better than anyone, did not perform collective du’a immediately after the funeral prayer. If this issue followed from the generality of this verse, they would certainly have made du’a. Therefore, the claim that from the generality of this verse the encouragement to make du’a immediately after the funeral prayer is derived is a clear falsehood.
③ The taqlid-adherents themselves do not hold that collective du’a in congregational form should be made before the funeral; so they do not act upon the generality of this verse.
④ Let them show that a Hanafi Imam derived evidence from this verse.

Evidence No. ➋

The Lord the Exalted says:

فَإِذَا فَرَغْتَ فَانْصَبْ ٭ وَإِلَى رَبِّكَ فَارْغَبْ

Reference: 104-al-Humazah:7

“So when you are free, then labour (in du’a), and turn your desire towards your Lord alone.”
Statements of the commentators on this verse:
It has been narrated in its explanation from Abdullah ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with both of them), and from Qatadah, Dahhak, Muqatil, al-Kalbi and others:

اذا فرغت من الصلاة المكتوبة أو مطلق الص لاة فانصب الي ربك فى الد عاء وار غب اليه فى المسئلة

“When you are free from the obligatory prayer or any kind of prayer, then engage in making du’a to your Lord and turn your desire toward asking from His court.”

Reference: Tafsir Mazhari: 94/10, India edition

Commentary:
① No reliable scholar has established from this noble verse the permissibility of collective supplication in the specific form immediately after the funeral prayer; therefore this argument is baseless.
② The tafsir attributed to Sayyiduna Ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) is not established, because in the first narration there is Ali bin Abi Talha, a narrator whose hearing from Sayyiduna Ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) is not established. In the second narration there is a “chain of the weak” (Silsilat al-Du’afa), namely Sa’d bin Muhammad bin al-Husayn, Atiyyah bin Sa’d al-Awfi, his paternal uncle al-Hasan bin Atiyyah al-Afi, al-Hasan bin Atiyyah al-Awfi, and Atiyyah al-Awfi; all of them are “da’if” (weak) narrators.
The narration of Dahhak حُدِّثتُ (it has been narrated to me), i.e. it is “da’if” due to unknown narrator status. Therefore both these narrations are “da’if”.
③ Muqatil is himself “da’if”.
④ Kalbi himself is kadhdhab (a liar) and matruk (abandoned).
⑤ قال الطبريٰ : حدثنا ابن عبد الأ عليٰ، قال : ثنا ثور عن معمر عن قتادة فى قوله : فاذا فرغت من صلاتك فانصب فى الد عاء۔
Imam Qatadah, explaining this verse, says: when you are free from your prayer, then exert yourself in supplication.

Reference: Tafsir al-Tabari: 152/3, and its chain is sahih

This authentic tafsir contains no mention of the funeral prayer. Secondly, it contains no mention of supplication in a collective form; its meaning is that when you are free from prayer, strive in supplication, i.e. recite the prescribed adhkar, or the meaning of this noble verse is that when you are free from worldly affairs, exert yourself greatly in worship.

Warning:

In explaining this verse, Khwaja Ya’qub Charkhi (d. 875 AH) writes:
“So when you are free from prayer, exert yourself in supplication; after prayer, present an offering and seek the meeting with the Truth (Allah), and ask for this world and the hereafter from Allah the Truth; when a servant prays and does not supplicate, (Allah) strikes his prayer in his face.”

Reference: Tafsir Ya’qub Charkhi: p. 157, old Hind edition

Response:
① The saying of Ya’qub Charkhi is baseless and rejected, being without evidence.
② This very point should be established from Imam Abu Hanifah and others with a sahih chain.
③ None among Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jama’ah has held this view.
④ It contains no mention of the funeral prayer or of a specific form.
⑤ According to the majority of Hanafi jurists, supplication after the funeral prayer is not correct; therefore this view is rejected.

Proof No. 3

Sayyiduna Abu Hurairah (may Allah be pleased with him) narrates that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:

إذا صليتم على الميت، فاخلصوا له الدعاء

“When you pray the funeral prayer over the deceased, then make supplication for him with sincerity.”

Reference: Sunan Abi Dawud 3199, Sunan Ibn Majah: 1497, al-Sunan al-Kubra lil-Bayhaqi: 40/4, and its chain is hasan

Commentary:
Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) (3077-3076) called this hadith “sahih”.
Its narrator Muhammad ibn Ishaq, author of al-Maghazi, is “hasan al-hadith” according to the majority; in Sahih Ibn Hibban he explicitly states hearing (sama’).
↰ From this hadith, the command is derived that one should make du’a with sincerity for the deceased during the funeral prayer; the muhaddithun have derived this very ruling from it.
◈ Imam Ibn Majah (may Allah have mercy on him) has a chapter heading on this as follows:

باب ما جاء فى الد عاء فى الصلاة على الجنازة

“The chapter on making du’a during the funeral prayer.”
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) ‘s chapter heading is in these words:

ذكر الأ مر لمن صلى على ميت أن يخلص له الد عاء

“The chapter on the command for one who prays the funeral prayer over a deceased person to make du’a for the deceased with sincerity.”
◈ Imam Bayhaqi (may Allah have mercy on him) establishes the chapter as follows:

باب فى الد عاء فى الصلاة الجنازة

“The chapter on making du’a during the funeral prayer.”
↰ The innovators present this hadith as evidence for collective du’a immediately after the funeral prayer. This is the handiwork of the people of innovation of our era; rather, it is a blatant distortion, having created an innovation by distorting the meaning of the hadith and disregarding the understanding and statements of the muhaddithun and of our own Hanafi jurists.
◈ Thus Ahmad Yar Khan Naimi Barelvi writes:
“The fa indicates that du’a should be made immediately after the prayer, without delay. Those who interpret it to mean that one should make du’a for him during the prayer neglect the meaning of “fa”. صلّیتم is the condition and فأخلصوا its response; there must be a difference between condition and response, not that one enters into the other. Then صليتم is past and فأخلصوا is an imperative; from this it is known that the command to make du’a is after completing the prayer, just as in فاذا طعمتم فانتشروا there is a command to leave after eating, not during eating… and فا only conveys emphasis.”

Reference: Jaa al-Haq: 274

See how the “Mufti” sahib, with such boldness, accuses the muhaddithun and his own Hanafi jurists and imams of “neglect”. Secondly, in one respect there is a difference here, namely the difference between the whole and the part: prayer, in terms of the whole, is the name of a collection of actions and statements, whereas du’a is a part of it, called a statement; a slight difference between condition and response is sufficient, otherwise the funeral prayer would have to be emptied of supplications, because a difference in every respect would only exist if there were no du’a at all within the funeral prayer. If a partial difference between condition and response suffices, then the difference exists here too.
Moreover, when “idha” enters upon a past verb, the meaning of the future is produced; therefore the correct meaning and translation is: “When you pray the funeral prayer, then make your du’a for this deceased person with sincerity.”
As is known from the understanding of the muhaddithun. If “fa” is taken to mean sequence everywhere, then

فإذا قرأت القرآن فاستعذ بالله من الشيطن الرجيم

would mean that after reading the Qur’an one should recite “a’udhu billah…” here too the recitation is past and “fa-sta’idh” is an imperative.
In the Qur’an, one verse establishes by way of indication (isharah al-nass) that making du’a immediately after the funeral prayer is not permissible, as Allah Most High says:
وَ لَا تُصَلِّ عَلٰیٓ اَحَدٍ مِّنۡہُمۡ مَّاتَ اَبَدًا وَّ لَا تَقُمۡ عَلٰی قَبۡرِہٖ

Reference: al-Tawbah: 84

“Never pray over any of them who has died, nor stand at his grave (to make du’a).”
When the Prophet ﷺ used to pray over the dead of the Muslims, he was prevented from praying over the hypocrites; likewise, if he had been making collective du’a for the deceased Muslim immediately after the funeral prayer, it would also have been prevented regarding the hypocrites. It is established that collective du’a immediately after the funeral prayer is not proven from the Sunnah of the Prophet.

Proof No. ➍

From Sayyiduna Abu Hurairah (may Allah be pleased with him) it is narrated:

ان النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم صلى على المنفوس، ثم قال : اللهم أعزه من عذاب القبر

“Verily the Prophet ﷺ prayed the funeral prayer over a newborn, then made du’a: O Allah, protect him from the punishment (trial) of the grave.”

Reference: Kanz al-Ummal: 716/15, new edition Halab

Reply:
① Its translation has been rendered incorrectly. The correct translation is: “Verily the Prophet ﷺ prayed the funeral prayer over a newborn and made du’a: O Allah, protect him from the punishment (trial) of the grave.”
In this narration, ثمّ is in the sense of “wa” (and); that is, he prayed the funeral prayer and in it recited this du’a, as is known from the understanding of the muhaddithun. To this day, no trustworthy muhaddith has presented it as proof of du’a immediately after the funeral.
② There is no mention in it of a collective form or of raising the hands in du’a.
③ To take the particle ثمّ in the sense of “fa”, i.e. sequence with immediate connection, is not correct here, because “thumma” is used for sequence with delay; to turn it towards sequence with immediate connection without any diverting indication is not correct, and the explicit statements of the Hanafi jurists also show this.

Proof No. ➎

From Sayyiduna Abdullah ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) it is narrated:

ان النبی صلى الله عليه وسلم قرأ علي الجنازة بفاحة الكتاب

“Verily the Prophet ﷺ recited al-Fatihah at a funeral.”

Reference: Mishkat al-Masabih with Ashi’at al-Lam’at: 686/1

Commentary:
This hadith is of the “hasan” grade. A supporting narration from Umm Sharik is present in Sunan Ibn Majah

Reference: 1496

; Imam Tabarani narrated it in his book al-Mu’jam al-Kabir

Reference: 91/25, H: 252

through the route of حماد بن بشير الجهضعمي عن أبى عبد الله الشامي (مرزوق) عن شهر بن حوشب. For further supporting narrations, see Majma’ al-Zawa’id

Reference: 32/3

.
This narration is a strong proof for reciting Surah al-Fatiha in the funeral prayer. The Barelwi leader Ahmad Yar Khan Na’imi Barelwi translated it in these words: “It is narrated from Hadrat Ibn Abbas that the Prophet ﷺ recited Surah al-Fatiha over a funeral.”

Reference: Mishkat Sharif translated by Ahmad Yar Khan Barelwi, Idara Islamia Urdu Bazar Lahore: 321/1, “Jaa al-Haqq”: 275/1

Therefore, translating it as “he recited al-Fatiha at the occasion of a funeral” is clearly a semantic distortion.
↰ الصلاة على الميّتّ refers to the funeral prayer, as in the hadith: صلّوا على صاحبكم meaning: “Perform the funeral prayer over your companion.”

Reference: Sahih al-Bukhari: 2397, Sahih Muslim: 1619

✿ The Almighty says in the Qur’an:

ولا تصلّ على أحد منهم مات أبدا

Reference: al-Tawbah: 84

“Never perform the funeral prayer over any of them (the hypocrites).”
This does not mean at all that “do not perform it at the occasion of a funeral.” !!!!
This translation is against the understanding of the muhaddithin; no trustworthy imam has derived this meaning from it.
Imam Ibn Majah, may Allah have mercy on him

Reference: 1495

, established the chapter ماجاء فى القراء ة على الجنازة on it; similarly, Imam al-Tirmidhi, may Allah have mercy on him, also established the chapter ماجاء فى القراءة على الجنازة on it, meaning the explanation of reciting during the funeral prayer.
From other authentic hadiths it is explicitly established that Surah al-Fatiha should be recited within the funeral prayer; therefore, the assumption of some people is false and rejected, as it contradicts authentic and explicit hadiths and the understanding of the muhaddithin.

Proof No. ➏

Abdullah ibn Abi Bakr, a Tabi’i, says:

لما التقي الناس بمئو نة جلس رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم على المنبر وكشف له ما بينه وبين الشام، فهو ينظر الي معر كتهم، فقال عليه السلام : أخذ الرأية زيد بن حرثة، فمضي حتي استشهد، وصلي عليه ودعا اله وقال : استخفر واله وقد دخل الجن ة، وهو يسعيٰ، ثم أخذ الرأية جعفر بن ابي طالب، فمضيٰ حتٰي استشهد، فصلي عليه رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم ودعا له وقال : استغفر واله، وقد دخل الجن ة، فهو يطير فيها بجنا حيه حيث شاء

“Whenever a calamity befell the people, the Messenger of Allah ﷺ would sit on the pulpit, and the area up to Syria would be made visible to him, so he would watch the battles of (the Muslims). He ﷺ said: Zayd ibn Haritha took the banner and kept going until he was martyred. He ﷺ prayed the funeral prayer over him and supplicated for him, and said: Supplicate for him; he has entered Paradise running. Then Ja’far ibn Abi Talib took the banner and kept going until he was martyred. The Messenger of Allah ﷺ prayed the funeral prayer over him and supplicated for him, and said: Supplicate for him; he has entered Paradise, and he flies in it with his two wings wherever he wishes.”

Reference: Kitab al-Maghazi by Muhammad ibn Umar al-Waqidi: 211/2, Nasb al-Raya: 284/2

Commentary:
This is a fabricated (mawdu’) narration.
Its narrator Muhammad ibn Umar al-Waqidi is, according to the majority, “da’if, matruk and kadhdhab (a liar).”
◈ Ibn al-Mulaqqin, may Allah have mercy on him, writes:
وقد ضعفه الجمهور “He has been declared weak by the majority.”

Reference: al-Badr al-Munir li Ibn al-Mulaqqin: 234/5

◈ Hafiz Ibn Hajar, may Allah have mercy on him, has called him “matruk.”

Reference: Taqrib al-Tahdhib: 6175

◈ Imam al-Shafi’i, may Allah have mercy on him, says:
كتب الواقدي كذب “The books of al-Waqidi are a bundle of lies.”

Reference: al-Jarh wa’l-Ta’dil li Ibn Abi Hatim: 21/8, its chain is sahih

◈ Imam Ishaq ibn Rahawayh, may Allah have mercy on him, says:

لأنه عندي ممن يضع الحديث

“In my view he is one who fabricates hadiths.”

Reference: al-Jarh wa’l-Ta’dil: 21/8

◈ Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, may Allah have mercy on him, has declared him “kadhdhab.”

Reference: al-Kamil li Ibn Adi: 241/6, its chain is hasan

◈ Imam al-Bukhari, Imam Abu Zur’ah, Imam al-Nasa’i and Imam al-Uqayli, may Allah have mercy on them, called him “matruk al-hadith”; Imam Yahya ibn Ma’in and the majority called him “da’if.”
◈ Imam Ibn Adi, may Allah have mercy on him, says:

يروي أحاديث غير محفوظة والبلاء منه، ومتون أخبار الواقدي غير محفوظة، وهو بين الضعف

“He narrates strange (ghayr) hadiths, and the calamity is from him; the texts of al-Waqidi’s hadiths are not preserved, and he is clearly a weak narrator.”

Reference: al-Kamil fi Du’afa’ al-Rijal li Ibn Adi: 243/6

➋ Its narrator Abd al-Jabbar ibn Umarah al-Qari is “majhul” (unknown).
Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi

Reference: al-Jarh wa’l-Ta’dil li Ibn Abi Hatim: 33/6

and Hafiz al-Dhahabi

Reference: Mizan al-I’tidal: 534/2

have declared him “majhul”; only Imam Ibn Hibban has mentioned him in al-Thiqat, which is insufficient.
➌ This narration is a mursal of a Tabi’i, so it is also “da’if” due to irsal.
It is impossible to establish a sunnah from a narration of this kind.

Proof No. ➐

Ibrahim al-Hijri says:

رأيت ابن أبى أبي أوفيٰ، وكان من أصحاب الژجرة، ماتت ابنته الي ان قال : ثم كبر عليها أربعا، ثم قام بعد ذلك قدر مابين التكبير تين يدعو وقال : رأيت رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم كان يصنع هكذا

“I saw Ibn Abi Awfa, who was a companion of the Pledge of Ridwan; his daughter passed away… he said four takbirs over her, then after that he stood for the length of the gap between two takbirs and supplicated, and said: I saw the Prophet ﷺ doing this.”

Reference: Jaa al-Haqq: 275, Miqyas-e-Hanafiyyat: 526, quoting Kanz al-Ummal: 2844

Commentary:
The chain of this narration is “weak” (da’if).
➊ In it, the narrator Ibrahim ibn Muslim al-Hajari is considered “weak” by the majority of scholars. Severe criticisms of him come from Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi, Imam al-Nasa’i, Imam al-Bukhari, Imam al-Tirmidhi, Imam Ibn ‘Adi, Imam Yahya ibn Ma’in, Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Imam al-Jawzajani, Imam Ibn Sa’d and Ibn Junayd, may Allah have mercy on them all.

Reference: See Tahdhib al-Tahdhib by Ibn Hajar: 144-143/1

Hafiz Ibn Hajar, may Allah have mercy on him, has called him “weak”.

Reference: Talkhis al-Mustadrak by al-Dhahabi: 555/1

➋ In it, the proof is found for supplication after the fourth takbir within the funeral prayer, not for an individual or collective supplication after the salam. In one narration there is also an explicit statement: وكبر على جنازة أربعا، ثم قام ساعة يد عو، ثم قال : أتر وني كنت أكبر خمسا، قالوا : لا . . . “He pronounced four takbirs over a funeral, then stood for a while making supplication, then said: Did you think I would say a fifth takbir? They said: No.”

Reference: Al-Sunan al-Kubra by al-Bayhaqi: 35/4, its chain is hasan if the hearing of al-Hasan ibn al-Sabah from Abu Ya’fur is authentic

Moreover, Imam al-Bayhaqi arranged this narration under the following chapter heading:

باب ماروي فى الاسخفار للميت والدعاء له مابين التكبيره الرابعة والسلام

“The narration of the chapter in which there is mention of supplication for the deceased between the fourth takbir and the salam.”

Reference: Al-Sunan al-Kubra by al-Bayhaqi: 43/4

↰ A muhaddith understands his own narration better than the innovators do; therefore this narration cannot give the slightest support to the Indian innovation.

Proof No. ➑

Abu Bakr ibn Mas’ud al-Kasani (d. 587 AH) narrates a hadith:

أن النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم صلى على جنازة، فلما فرغ جاء عمر ومعه قوم، فأر ادأن يصلي ثانيا، فقال له النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم صلى : الصلاة على الجنازة لا تعاد، ولكن ادع للميت واستغفرله

“Indeed the Prophet ﷺ prayed the funeral prayer over a deceased person. When he had finished, Umar arrived with a group along with him, and he intended to pray the funeral prayer again. The Prophet ﷺ said to him: The funeral prayer is not repeated; rather, now make supplication and seek forgiveness for the deceased.”

Reference: Badai’ al-Sana’i fi Tartib al-Shara’i’: 777/2, Hamidiyya Egyptian edition

Commentary:
➊ This narration is without a chain, fabricated (mawdu’), baseless, false, a lie, invented, contrived, fabricated, without foundation and without origin, and it is a forgery and a lie against Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.
➋ From the words ذعُ it becomes clear that he (Umar) should make supplication himself, not that he should join our (the Prophet’s) supplication.

Proof No. ➓

From Sayyiduna Mu’adh ibn Jabal, may Allah be pleased with him, it is narrated that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
A believer who loves the recitation of the Qur’an, when he dies,

فتصلي الملائكة على روحه فى الأ رواح، ثم تستغفر له . . . .

then the angels perform the funeral prayer over his spirit in the world of souls, and then they seek forgiveness for him…”

Reference: Sharh al-Sudur: p., printed in Egypt

Commentary:
This narration is extremely “weak” (da’if), as Hafiz al-Suyuti, may Allah have mercy on him, writes after mentioning it:

هذا حديث غريب فى اسناده جهالة وانقطاع

“This hadith is gharib; its chain contains an unknown narrator and a break (inqita’).”

Reference: Sharh al-Sudur: 53

This narration was quoted from Hafiz al-Suyuti’s book, but the ruling he gave on it was not mentioned, which is a clear act of dishonesty.
➋ Regarding this narration, Imam al-Bazzar himself says:
خالد بن معد ان لم يسمع من معاذ. “Khalid ibn Ma’dan did not hear from Sayyiduna Mu’adh, may Allah be pleased with him.”

Reference: Kashf al-Astar: 812

Hafiz al-Mundhiri, may Allah have mercy on him, after mentioning this cause of weakness, writes:

في اسناد ه من لا يعرف حاله، وفي متنه غرابة كثير ة، بل نكارة ظاهرة

“Its chain also contains a narrator whose circumstances could not be known, and its text has much strangeness, indeed apparent nakarah (rejection).”

Reference: al-Targhib wa al-Tarhib: 245/1

➌ It does not mention supplication immediately after the funeral prayer; rather, it mentions that when he (the monotheist) dies, the angels immediately make supplication for him. The meaning of salah of the angels is supplication, and the angels’ supplication for believers means asking forgiveness for them, not performing the funeral prayer. When salah here does not mean prayer at all, how does دعا بعد الصلاة (supplication after the prayer) come in?
The words اليٰ يوم البعث are dishonestly omitted; they show that they continue to make supplication of forgiveness for him until the Day of Resurrection. Secondly, we are not obligated to the actions and words of the angels; for us, the textual evidences of the Shari’ah are proof, and nor are the angels obligated to this Shari’ah.

Proof No. ⓫

Umayr ibn Sa’d narrates:

صليت مع على علي يزيد بن المكفف، فكبر عليه أربعا، ثم مشيي حتي أتاه، فقال : اللهم عبدكه وابن عبدكه نزل بك اليوم، فاغفر له ذنبه ووسع عليه مد خله،، ثم مشيي حتي أتاه وقال : اللهم عبدك وابن عبد ك نزل بك اليوم، فاغفر له ذنبه ووسع عليه مد خه، فانا لا نعلم منه الا خير ا وأنت أعلم نه

“I prayed the funeral prayer over Yazid ibn Mukaffif along with Sayyiduna Ali, may Allah be pleased with him. Ali pronounced four takbirs over him (in the funeral prayer), then walked and came near the grave, then made this supplication: O Allah! This is Your servant and the son of Your servant, who has come to You today; so forgive his sins and widen his grave for him. Then he walked on and, drawing even closer, began to supplicate: O Allah! Your servant and the son of Your servant has come to Your presence today; so You forgive his sins and widen his grave for him, for we know nothing of him except good, and You know him better.”

Reference: Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah: 331/3, Bombay, India edition

Commentary:
➊ This narration has no connection with supplication immediately after the funeral prayer. Its connection is with supplication at the grave after burial, as the classification by the muhaddithun shows. Imam Ibn Abi Shaybah (may Allah have mercy on him) cited this narration under في الدعاء للميت بعد ما يد فن ويسوي عليه, meaning he presented this hadith in the chapter on supplication after the deceased has been buried and the earth has been leveled over him.
Similarly, Imam Abd al-Razzaq (may Allah have mercy on him) classified this hadith with this heading:

في الدعاء للميت حين يفرغ منه

“The chapter on supplicating for the deceased when one has finished with him (burying him).”

Reference: Musannaf Abd al-Razzaq: 509/3

Notice that two great imams of Ahl al-Sunnah are presenting this narration as evidence for supplication after burial. The understanding of the muhaddithun takes precedence, for they knew their narrations better than others.
➋ Walking (to the grave) means that he performed the funeral prayer, came to the grave, and made supplication at the grave after burial. Indeed, in the narration of Sunan al-Kubra al-Bayhaqi

Reference: 56/4

there is explicit mention that: وقد أدخل ميتا فى قبره، فقال : اللهم . . . “He had already placed the deceased in the grave and then made supplication: O Allah!…”
➌ This narration also makes no mention of a collective form.

Evidence No. 12

عن أبى هريرة رضى الله عنه اننه صلى على المنفوس، ثم قال : اللهم أعذه من عذاب القبر

“It is narrated from Sayyiduna Abu Hurairah (may Allah be pleased with him) that he performed the funeral prayer over a newborn infant, then made this supplication: O Allah! Protect him from the trial of the grave.”

Reference: As-Sunan al-Kubra lil-Bayhaqi: 9/4

Commentary:
➊ The translation of this has been done incorrectly; the correct translation is:
It is narrated from Hadrat Sa’id bin Musayyib, who said: I prayed the funeral prayer over that child who had never committed any sin, behind Hadrat Abu Hurairah, but I heard him say: O Allah! Save him from the punishment of the grave.

Reference: Mishkat Sharif, translation by Ahmad Yar Khan Na’imi Barelvi: 364/1

➋ Imam Malik (may Allah have mercy on him), the Imam of Ahl al-Sunnah, has cited this narration under باب مايقول المصلي على الجنازة “The chapter on what the one who prays the funeral prayer recites during the funeral prayer.”

Reference: Al-Muwatta: 228/1

➌ For further answers, see under Hadith No. 1.
➍ There is no evidence in it for reciting Fatiha and the four Qul immediately after the funeral prayer, nor is there any mention of a collective form.

Evidence No. 13

Kasani narrates:

ان ابن عباس وابن عمر رضي الله تعالىٰ عنهم فاتتهما سلاة على الجنازة، فلما حضرا زادا على الا ستغفار له۔ واللفط للكاساني

“Sayyiduna Ibn Abbas and Ibn Umar missed a funeral prayer, and when they arrived they did nothing for it except supplicate for forgiveness for him.”

Reference: Al-Mabsut: 67/2, Beirut edition; Badai al-Sanai: 777/2

Commentary:
This narration is without a chain, fabricated (mawdu’), baseless, false, forged, invented, contrived, groundless and without origin. Only one who is a devotee of innovations and an enemy of the Sunnah can present such false and chainless narrations. The books of the “jurists” of the Muqallids are filled with such nonsense; in their religion there is no such thing as a chain, which is why the muhaddithun did not regard them favorably. فافهم وتدبر !

Evidence No. 14

Sayyiduna Abu Umamah al-Bahili (may Allah be pleased with him) narrates that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ was asked: Which supplication is most accepted? He said:

جوف الليل الآ خر ودهر الصلوات المكتوابات

“The last half of the night and after the obligatory prayers.”

Reference: Sunan al-Tirmidhi: 3499; Amal al-Yawm wal-Laylah lil-Nasai: 108

Commentary:
Its chain is “da’if” due to a break (inqita’),
the narrator Abd al-Rahman bin Sabat did not hear from Sayyiduna Abu Umamah (may Allah be pleased with him).
Imam Yahya bin Ma’in (may Allah have mercy on him) says that Abd al-Rahman bin Sabit did not hear from Sayyiduna Abu Umamah.”

Reference: Tarikh Yahya bin Ma’in: 366

Hafiz Ibn al-Qattan al-Fasi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:

واعلم أن مايرويه عبد الرحمن بن سابط عن أبى أما مة ليس بمتصل، وانما هو منقطع، لم يسمع منه

“Know that the narrations which Abd al-Rahman bin Sabit narrates from Sayyiduna Abu Umamah are not connected at all; they are broken (munqati’), because Abd al-Rahman bin Sabit did not hear from Sayyiduna Abu Umamah (may Allah be pleased with him).”

Reference: Nasb al-Rayah lil-Zayla’i: 235/2; Bayan al-Wahm wal-Iham: 385/2

Evidence No. 15

Sayyiduna Anas bin Malik (may Allah be pleased with him) narrates that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:

مامن عبد بسط كفيه فى دبر كل صلاة، ثم يقول : اللهم الهي واله ابراهيم واسحاق ويعقوب اله جبرئيل وميكائيل واسرافيل عليهم السلام ! أسأل أن تستجيب دعوتي، فاني مضطر، وتعصمني فى ديني، فاني مبتلي، وتنا والني برحمتك، فاني مزنب، وتفي عني الفقر فاني متمسكن، الا كان حقا على الله عز وجل ان لا ير د يه خاليتين

“Whoever spreads out his two palms after every prayer and says: O Allah, O my God and the God of Ibrahim, Ishaq, Ya’qub, Jibra’il, Mika’il, Israfil, peace be upon them! I ask You to accept my supplication, for I am helpless; grant me protection in my religion, for I am afflicted with trials; have mercy on me with Your mercy, for I am a sinner; and remove poverty from me, for I am destitute, it is incumbent upon Allah Almighty that He does not return his two hands empty.”

Reference: Amal al-Yawm wal-Laylah lil-Ibn al-Sunni: 129

Commentary:
This narration is fabricated (mawdu’), because:
➊ Its narrator Abd al-Aziz bin Abd al-Rahman al-Qurashi al-Balisi is “matruk” (abandoned).
Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal (may Allah have mercy on him) says:

اضرب على احاديثه، هي كذب، ا و قال: موضوعة

“Discard its narrations; they are lies.”

Reference: Al-Jarh wal-Ta’dil by Ibn Abi Hatim: 388/5

Imam al-Nasai (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
ليس بثقة “He is not reliable (thiqah).”

Reference: Al-Du’afa wal-Matrukun: p. 211

Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:

وعبد العزيز هذا يروي عن خصيف احاديث بواطيل

“He narrates false narrations from Khasif.”

Reference: Al-Kamil by Ibn Adi: 289/5

➋ Abd al-Aziz narrated this from Khasif al-Jazari, who is a narrator whose reliability is disputed; moreover, he did not hear from Sayyiduna Anas (may Allah be pleased with him).
➌ Regarding Ishaq bin Khalid bin Yazid al-Balisi, Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:

ورواياته تدل عممن روي عنه بأنه ضعيف

“His narrations indicate that whoever he narrated from, he is in any case weak (da’if).”

Reference: Al-Kamil by Ibn Adi: 344/1

Readers! To establish supplication immediately after the funeral prayer in a collective form from this narration is equivalent to killing justice and knowledge.

Evidence No. 16

عن عبدالله بن سلام أنه فاتته الصلاة على جنازة عمر رضي الله تعالىٰ عنه، فلما حضر قال : ان سبقتموني باالصلاة عليه، فلا تسبقوني بالدعا ء اله

Sayyidina Abdullah ibn Salam (may Allah be pleased with him) missed the funeral prayer for Sayyidina Umar (may Allah be pleased with him). When he arrived, he said: “If you have already prayed over him before me, then do not get ahead of me in supplicating for him.”

Reference: al-Mabsut: 67/2, published Beirut; Badai al-Sanai: 7772/2, new edition Egypt

Commentary:
➊ This narration is without a chain (bila sanad), fabricated (mawdu’), baseless (batil), false, unfounded and without origin. It is not found in any book of hadith. It is true that as long as Satan and his companions exist in the world, the flow of false narrations will continue.
➋ Its meaning is that if you have prayed the funeral prayer before me, then include me in the supplication after burial.

Argument No. ⓱

Abd al-Wahhab Sha’rani writes:

ومن ذلك قول ابي حنيفة : ان التعزية سنة قبل الدفن لابعده۔۔۔ لأن شدة الحزن انما تكون قبل الدفن، فيغري ويدعي له

“Among these issues is the view of Imam Abu Hanifa that condolence is a Sunnah before burial, not after burial… because the intensity of grief occurs only before burial, so condolence and supplication for the deceased should be made (before burial).”

Reference: Kitab Mizan al-Shari’a al-Kubra: 185/1, published Egypt

Commentary:
Prove a sound chain from Abd al-Wahhab Sha’rani back to Abu Hanifa, otherwise the people of innovation should accept that they do not hesitate to attribute lies even to Imam Abu Hanifa.

Argument No. ⓲

After quoting the statement of مفتي ٰ به روايت صاحب كشف الغطاء مانعين, he writes: “It is permissible to recite Fatiha and supplicate for the deceased before burial. This same narration is the practice of مفتٰي به, and it is likewise in Khulasat al-Fiqh.”

Reference: al-Atayya al-Nabawiyya fi al-Fatawa al-Radawiyya: 30/4, published Lyallpur

Commentary:
➊ This statement is rejected and false, as it has no evidence.
➋ It also contradicts the explicit statements of the majority of Hanafi jurists.
➌ Let the muqallidun clarify: are they followers of Imam Abu Hanifa or of the author of “Kashf al-Ghita'”?

Argument No. ⓳

The explicit statement of a Hanafi jurist
Abd al-Ali al-Barjandi narrates from Muhammad ibn al-Fadl:

قال محمد بن الفضل : لا بأس به أي بالدعاء بعد صلاة الجنازة

“Muhammad ibn al-Fadl said that there is no harm in supplication after the funeral prayer.”

Reference: Barjandi, Sharh Mukhtasar al-Waqaya: 180/1, Nawalkishori edition

Commentary:
➊ Barjandi the Hanafi took this statement of Muhammad ibn al-Fadl from the author of “al-Qunya” al-Zahidi, who was a Mu’tazili. The Barelwi scholar Ahmad Yar Khan Na’imi Gujarati writes: “Al-Qunya is an unreliable book; fatwa is not given on it. In the introduction of Shami, in the discussion on the etiquette of the mufti, it is mentioned that the author of al-Qunya also takes weak narrations, and it is not permissible to issue a fatwa on it. A’la Hazrat (Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi), may his secret be sanctified, said in Zazl al-Jawa’iz that the author of al-Qunya was a Mu’tazili, a people of innovation.”

Reference: Jaa al-Haqq: 281/1

The Barelwi imam Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi himself writes: “There is no reliance on its transmission.”

Reference: Bazl al-Jawa’iz, appended to Fatawa Radawiyya: 254/9

➋ Let the muqallidun explain whether they follow Muhammad ibn al-Fadl or Imam Abu Hanifa, and let them prove from their imam, with a sound chain, the permissibility of collective supplication immediately after the funeral prayer.
➌ The statement of Muhammad ibn al-Fadl is also rejected in comparison with the majority of Hanafi jurists.
➍ In this book, citing “al-Qunya,” it is written: عن أبى بكر بن أبى حامد أن الدعا ء بعد سلاة الجنازة مكروه “It is narrated from Abu Bakr ibn Hamid al-Hanafi that supplication after the funeral prayer is disliked (makruh).” The statement is supported in Fatawa Fayd Karkhi.

Conclusion:
The two Qur’anic verses presented as evidence for supplication immediately after the funeral prayer, and the hadiths presented in the third, fourth and fifth arguments, have no connection with this issue.
The hadith presented under the sixth argument is fabricated (mawdu’), baseless and rejected. The hadith mentioned in the seventh argument is “da’if” (weak), and besides that it is also irrelevant to the topic, because it mentions supplication after the fourth takbir and before the salam.
The hadiths mentioned under the eighth and ninth arguments are also fabricated and severely weak (da’if). The hadith presented under the tenth and eleventh arguments also has no connection with raising the hands for collective supplication immediately after the funeral prayer.
Therefore, by the grace and favour of Allah, having examined the evidence put forward in support of this innovation, we have established that supplication immediately after the funeral prayer is an ugly innovation (bid’ah qabihah).

Ten Questions
From those who emphasise this innovation, answers are sought to these ten questions:
➊ Present explicit textual evidence from the Prophet ﷺ permitting supplication immediately after the funeral prayer!
➋ Present at least one “da’if” hadith from the Prophet ﷺ proving collective supplication in the manner of immediately following the funeral prayer, in which it is explicitly stated that collective supplication follows the funeral prayer!
➌ Prove with a sound chain that any single companion of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ made supplication immediately after the funeral prayer!
➍ Prove, with a “da’if” narration, that a companion made supplication immediately after the funeral prayer, in which the supplication after the funeral prayer is explicitly mentioned!
➎ Present proof from a fabricated (mawdu’) hadith from the Prophet ﷺ of supplication immediately after the funeral prayer!
➏ Present a fabricated (mawdu’) narration from a companion in which it is mentioned that he made supplication immediately after the funeral prayer!
➐ Prove from Imam Abu Hanifa, with a sound chain, the permissibility of supplication immediately after the funeral prayer!
➑ Prove its permissibility from the most authoritative book of Hanafi fiqh!
➒ Prove with a sound chain that any reliable imam performed collective supplication with raised hands immediately after the funeral prayer!
➓ Name a reliable imam who, from the above arguments, proved the permissibility of supplication immediately after the funeral prayer, or who established a chapter for it!