Detailed Statement of the Question:
Muhammad Yousuf son of Sadr Din is an imam in a mosque and also teaches children the Quran. Muhammad Aslam son of Khushi Muhammad has an old and brotherly relationship with Maulvi Yousuf. Muhammad Aslam comes to Maulvi Yousuf with his son Muhammad Akram and requests that Muhammad Akram be taught Quran and Hadith. Along with this, he also declares:
“From today, Muhammad Akram is your son. We will never say that Muhammad Akram is our son; rather, we ourselves will say that Muhammad Akram is Maulvi Yousuf’s son.”
At that time, Muhammad Akram was about six or seven years old.
Maulvi Yousuf’s Course of Action:
- Maulvi Yusuf treated Muhammad Akram exactly like his own sons.
- He also bore the expenses of clothes, food, and school education himself.
- All this was done with the sole intention of considering Muhammad Akram as his own son.
- Muhammad Akram also calls Maulvi Yusuf “Abaji” with feelings of love and respect.
- Muhammad Aslam son of Khushi Muhammad is very happy about this:
“When we have made our son the son of Maulvi Yusuf, then he is now his father.”
But at the same time, Muhammad Aslam is also well aware that Muhammad Akram is his real son, and Muhammad Akram also treats his father Aslam in the same way a son treats his father.
Economic Conditions and Intention:
- Muhammad Aslam, son of Khushi Muhammad, did not entrust his son to Maulvi Yusuf due to poverty or financial compulsion.
- He is financially self-sufficient, owns his own land, and holds the position of headmaster at a school.
- This entire matter was done purely on the basis of old relations and respect for the teacher.
Muhammad Akram’s youth and behavior:
- Now Muhammad Akram has grown up and calls Maulvi Yusuf “Abaji” so as not to hurt his feelings.
- Maulvi Yusuf has shown more affection to Muhammad Akram than even to his own sons, and if Muhammad Akram stops calling him “Abaji,” it will deeply hurt Maulvi Sahib.
Change of parentage in the identity card:
- Keeping this spirit of love and respect in mind, Muhammad Aslam himself filled out the identity card form and went to the office to have “Maulvi Yusuf” recorded as Muhammad Akram’s father.
- Aslam also said:
“After all, the one who raised him like his own son should be recorded as the father. If he were mine, my parentage would have been written.”
The central point of the question:
This entire matter is solely based on love, respect, and courtesy. It is neither a real father-son relationship nor has there been any legal or Sharia-based change in parentage. The question is:
Is this behavior correct according to Sharia?
Answer:
Praise be to Allah, and prayers and peace be upon the Messenger of Allah, and thereafter!
In the first Ruku of سورۃ الاحزاب, instructions related to the adopted son are mentioned. The summary of these instructions is as follows:
Sharia Guidelines:
- Muhammad Akram should stop calling Maulvi Muhammad Yousuf “Abaji” (father).
- It is obligatory to change the parentage recorded on the identity card.
Instead of “Muhammad Akram son of Muhammad Yousuf,” it should be written as “Muhammad Akram son of Muhammad Aslam.”
Maulvi Muhammad Yousuf also does not have the right to call or show Muhammad Akram as his son.
There is no harm in friendship, brotherly relations, love, respect, and service.
- Maintaining these relations is permissible.
- Serving each other is also correct.
True Joy and Happiness:
For a believer, true happiness and success lie in adhering to the commands of Allah Almighty and His Messenger, peace be upon him.
ھذا ما عندي والله أعلم بالصواب