Shaykh Abu al-Hasan (al-Daraqutni) said: Uthman bin Abi Shaybah, al-Humaydi and several other narrators transmitted it from Abu Usamah, from al-Walid bin Kathir, from Muhammad bin Abbad bin Ja'far; al-Shafi'i also transmitted it the same way from a trustworthy teacher of his, from al-Walid bin Kathir. But Ya'qub bin Ibrahim al-Dawraqi and those we mentioned with him at the beginning transmitted it from Abu Usamah, from al-Walid bin Kathir, from Muhammad bin Ja'far bin al-Zubayr. Since there was a disagreement about its chain from Abu Usamah, we wished to know who had it right. We examined it and found that Shu'ayb bin Ayyub transmitted it from Abu Usamah, from al-Walid bin Kathir, both ways: from Muhammad bin Ja'far bin al-Zubayr, and then from Muhammad bin Abbad bin Ja'far. So both versions are established as correct from Abu Usamah, and it is established that al-Walid bin Kathir transmitted it from both Muhammad bin Ja'far bin al-Zubayr and Muhammad bin Abbad bin Ja'far, from Abdullah bin Abdullah bin Umar, from his father (Sayyiduna Abdullah bin Umar, may Allah be pleased with them both). Abu Usamah would sometimes narrate it through one of them and sometimes through the other, and Allah knows best. As for the narration of Shu'ayb bin Ayyub from both men, (it follows).