A man who says to another: You wine drinker

Mughirah said that it is reported from Ibrahim concerning a person who says to a man: O drinker of wine. He said: No prescribed punishment (hadd) is to be carried out on him.

Ash'ath said that it is reported from al-Hasan al-Basri concerning a person who says to a man: O drinker of wine, O drunkard. He did not consider the prescribed punishment (hadd) due from him.

Ibn Jurayj said that it is reported from Ata concerning a person who says to a man: O drunkard, O thief. He said: No prescribed punishment (hadd) is due from him, but he is to be given some lashes.

Sulayman bin Musa said: We asked Umar bin Abd al-Aziz about a man who says to a man: O drinker of wine, or O polytheist, or O drunkard. We asked: Is he to be punished? He said: Subhan Allah (Glory be to Allah)! No one is to be punished except the one who falsely accuses a Muslim.

Jabir said that it is reported from Amir concerning a person who says to a man: O drinker of wine: He is not to be struck.