Those who said he is liable to the hadd punishment if he says: You sodomite

Hammad reports that Ibrahim said: "Whoever falsely accuses a person of this is to be flogged, and witnesses are to be sought in it just as they are sought in the case of witnesses to unlawful sexual intercourse (zina)."

Ma'mar reports that al-Zuhri said: "When a man accuses another of the deed of the people of Lut, or of an indecent act with an animal, he is to be flogged."

Abd al-Khaliq reports that Hammad said: "The prescribed punishment for false accusation is to be applied to him."

Abd al-Hamid bin Jubayr reports that a man said to another man: "O Luti!" This matter was presented before Umar bin Abd al-Aziz, and he began to say: "O Luti! O Muhammadi!" The narrator says: Then he gave him more than ten lashes, then the next day he brought him out and completed his punishment.

Abu Hilal reports that al-Hasan al-Basri said: "The prescribed punishment for false accusation is not to be applied to him." And Ikrimah said: "The prescribed punishment for false accusation is to be applied to him."

And Ikrimah said: The prescribed punishment (hadd) applies to him.