Two slaves, one of whom is wounded

Mughirah and Hammad said it is reported from Ibrahim, regarding two slaves one of whom gouged out the eye of his companion, that he said: "If the two are equal in value, the eye will be gouged out in return for the eye; and if one of them is of greater value than the other, the one of greater value will be returned against the one of lesser value."

Hammad reported from Ibrahim, regarding two slaves one of whom gouges out the eye of his companion, that he said: "If the two are equal in value, it is an eye for an eye; and if one of them is of greater value than the other, the greater is returned against the lesser."

Ibn Jurayj said: I asked Ata about a slave who deliberately killed another slave, the slain being better than the killer: what is the ruling? He said: "The masters of the slain get only the killer of their slave; they get nothing besides him." And Amr bin Dinar said in reply to this: "They get only the killer of their slave; if they wish they may kill him, and if they wish they may enslave him."

Amr bin Dinar said the same: "They get only the killer of their slave; if they wish they may kill him, and if they wish they may enslave him."