A man who gives a slave girl in charity to his mother

It is narrated from al-Harith that a man gave a slave-girl in charity to his mother. Then he married a woman and gave the slave-girl to his wife. They then took their dispute to Shurayh, and Shurayh said to his mother: "Your son did not give you his charity as a gift."

Ibrahim deemed the slave-girl to be the property of the mother, unless he brings witnesses that he gave her as dowry before giving her in charity (as a gift).