Those who said: his testimony is not valid even when he repents

Shurayh said: When the prescribed punishment (hadd) for false accusation is carried out on a person, his testimony will never be accepted, and his repentance is a matter between him and Allah.

Shurayh said that the testimony of a person who makes a false accusation is not valid, and his repentance is a matter between him and Allah.

Abu al-Haytham said that Ibrahim and al-Sha'bi were discussing the testimony of a person who makes a false accusation. Ibrahim said that his testimony will not be accepted. Al-Sha'bi asked him the reason, and Ibrahim said: "You do not know whether he has repented or not."

Al-Hasan said about a person who makes a false accusation that his repentance is a matter between him and Allah, and his testimony is not valid.

Al-Hasan and Sa'id bin al-Musayyib said that such a person has no testimony, and his repentance is a matter between him and Allah.

Sayyiduna Abdullah bin Amr (may Allah be pleased with him) said that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said: "All Muslims are upright (that is, their testimony concerning one another will be accepted), except those on whom the prescribed punishment (hadd) has been carried out for false accusation."

Ibrahim said that the testimony of one who makes a false accusation of unchastity is not accepted, and his repentance is a matter between him and Allah.