A man having intercourse with a Magian slave girl: those who disliked it

Musa bin Abi A'ishah said: I asked Murrah: If a man buys a Magian slave-girl or takes her captive, may he have intercourse with her before she accepts Islam? He said: "That is not right."

And I asked Sa'id bin Jubayr, and he said: "If he does that, he is no better than her."

Makhul said: If a slave-girl is a Magian, one may not marry her until she becomes a Muslim.

Al-Zuhri said: As long as a Magian woman does not affirm 'La ilaha illallah' (there is no god but Allah), a Muslim man may not go near her. When she affirms it, she is a Muslim.

Abu Salamah said: A Muslim may not go near a Magian woman before she accepts Islam.

Al-Hasan said: It is not right to have intercourse with a Magian woman.

Ibrahim said: When Magian and idol-worshipping women are taken captive, Islam is to be presented to them. If they accept Islam, it is permissible both to have intercourse with them and to take service from them. If they do not accept Islam, intercourse will not be had with them, but service may be taken from them.

Sa'id bin al-Musayyib said: There is no harm in buying a Magian slave-girl and taking her as a concubine.

Muthanna said: In the view of Ata, Tawus and Amr bin Dinar, it is permissible to take a Magian slave-girl as a concubine.

And Sa'id bin al-Musayyib disliked it.

Rabi' bin Khuthaym said: When you obtain a polytheist slave-girl, do not have intercourse with her until she accepts Islam and takes a ritual bath (ghusl).