A man who shoots game while he is in the Haram

Qatadah was asked about a man who is in the Haram and shoots game that is outside it (in the hill), or who is outside the Haram while the game is in the Haram. He said: He owes its ransom and compensation.

Al-Hasan was asked: If a man shoots game that is in the Haram, and the game leaves the Haram and dies? He said: He is liable for it. And if he shoots game outside the Haram while the game is also outside it, and then it enters the Haram and dies? He said: He is not liable.

Hammad says concerning a man who shoots game outside the boundaries of the Haram and the game goes into the Haram and dies: In my view, what is preferable is that he not eat it.

Ata says: If game is shot outside the boundaries of the Haram and it enters the Haram and dies, he should not eat it, because it died in the Haram, and he does not pay compensation for it, because it was shot outside the boundaries of the Haram.

Something similar is reported from Ata (through another chain).

Sayyiduna Jabir (may Allah be pleased with him) says: If he shoots from outside the Haram and hits the game inside the Haram, he must make expiation; and if he shoots from inside the Haram and hits the game outside it, he must make expiation.