Those who said: if he has taken a sacrificial camel upon himself, he slaughters it in Makkah

A person asked Sayyiduna Ibn Umar (may Allah be pleased with them both): I swore an oath, or I made the sacrifice of a camel binding upon myself; may I slaughter it in this land where I am? He said: No, do not slaughter it anywhere other than the place for sacrificial camels. The man said: But I said that I would slaughter it right where I am? Sayyiduna Abdullah bin Umar refused and said: Satan makes things seem fair to whomever he wishes.

Waqa' said: I mentioned to Sa'id bin Jubayr this statement of Sayyiduna Ibn Umar (may Allah be pleased with them both): Slaughter it in Makkah. He said: I was not aware of it.

Al-Hasan, al-Sha'bi and Ata say that whoever is obliged to sacrifice a camel (badanah) should sacrifice it in Makkah; and whoever says (in his vow) a jazur or a cow (feminine) may sacrifice it wherever he wishes and wherever he intends.

Al-Sha'bi and Ata said: Whoever takes a badanah (sacrificial camel) upon himself must sacrifice it in Makkah; and if he said: a jazur or a cow, then (he may sacrifice it) wherever he wishes and wherever he intended.

Ata says that when a person makes a camel obligatory upon himself, he should sacrifice it at the place he named; and if he did not name any place, he should slaughter it in Makkah.

Salim bin Abdullah was asked about the sacrifice of camels (badanah). He said that a badanah does not suffice anywhere except in this town, that is, Makkah.

Sa'id bin Jubayr and Ikrimah say that there is no place of sacrifice for camels other than Makkah (the Ka'bah).

Sa'id bin al-Musayyib says concerning a person who is obliged to sacrifice a camel: he may slaughter it wherever he wishes, and slaughter it at the place he intends.

It is narrated from Jahm al-Bakri that a man vowed to slaughter a camel in Kufah; then he asked Sayyiduna Ibn Mas'ud (may Allah be pleased with him), and he said: Slaughter it wherever you wish.

Sayyiduna Ibn Umar (may Allah be pleased with them both) says that whoever makes a vow using the word badanah (masculine) should slaughter it in Makkah only, and whoever vows a she-camel (jazur) or a cow may slaughter it wherever he wishes.

Ibrahim and al-Hasan say that what counts is his intention.

Al-Hasan (together with Ibrahim) said: What counts is his intention.

Sayyiduna Ibn Umar (may Allah be pleased with them both) says that whoever vows a camel (badanah) should slaughter it at Mina or Makkah, and whoever vows a she-camel (jazur) may slaughter it wherever he wishes.

Sa'id bin al-Musayyib and al-Hasan say that when someone vows in these words, "A hady (sacrificial animal) is due from me," he should slaughter it in Makkah, and when he says badanah, he may slaughter it wherever he wishes.

Maymun says that whoever makes a camel (badanah) obligatory upon himself should slaughter it in Makkah only, and whoever vows a she-camel (jazur) may slaughter it wherever he wishes.