Those Who Consider Fasting During Travel Invalid

Hazrat Ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with both of them) was asked whether a fast kept during travel is sufficient? He replied, "No."

Hazrat Muharrar bin Abi Hurairah says that I kept a fast during travel in Ramadan, so Hazrat Abu Hurairah said to me that when you reach your area, keep this fast again.

Hazrat Abu Faiz narrates that we were in a battle expedition and a certain person was our leader. He said that whoever wishes may fast and whoever wishes may not fast. Abu Faiz says that I met a companion, Hazrat Abu Qarsafah, and I asked him about this matter. He replied that if I fast and then fast again, I have not made up (any missed fasts).

A person narrates that once a man kept a fast during travel in Ramadan, so Hazrat Umar ordered him to repeat the fast.