Mughirah narrates that I came to Ibrahim al-Nakha'i and said that a man named Sa'd had quarrelled with me. Then he mentioned the whole hadith and said that Ibrahim said: "This Sa'd came to me once as well, and he claimed that he had said to his wife: 'Every wife of mine other than you is divorced three times.' At that I said that Judge Shurayh used to say: 'When the speech begins with divorce, it falls on that woman too.' Then news reached me that when the man went out from there, he said: 'Is this anything but people's own opinion?' Then I learned that, out of caution and piety, he left her." Jarir says: Then I met Sa'id al-Zubaydi and asked him about this matter, and he said: "I asked Sa'id bin Jubayr (may Allah have mercy on him) about this, and he said: 'Divorce does not fall on her.'" Then al-Zubaydi said: "Take note! Had I been on that day in the state of knowledge I am in today, I would not have divorced my wife."