Did a Tree Grant Refuge to Prophet Zakariyya (علیہ السلام)?

اردو میں پڑھیں
Font size:
Written by: Ghulam Mustafa Zaheer Amanpuri (may Allah preserve him)

Question:

Did a tree give shelter to Sayyidna Zakariya (peace be upon him)?

Answer:

There is no truth in this matter. In a lengthy narration about the Mi’raj, the following dialogue of Sayyidna Zakariya (peace be upon him) with the Messenger of Allah ﷺ is reported:

قالت بنو إسرائيل: قد غضب إله زكريا لزكريا، فتعالوا حتى نغضب لملكنا فنقتل زكريا، قال فخرجوا فى طلبي ليقتلوني وجاءني الندير فهربت منهم وإبليس أمامهم يدلهم على فلما تخوفت أن لا أعجزهم عرضت لي شجرة فنادتني وقالت إلى إلى وانصدعت لي ودخلت فيها. قال وجاء إبليس حتى أخذ بطرف ردائي والتأمت الشجرة وبقي طرف ردائي خارجا من الشجرة، وجاءت بنو إسرائيل فقال إبليس: أما رأيتموه دخل هذه الشجرة هذا طرف ردائه دخلها بسحره، فقالوا نحرق هذه الشجرة، فاق إبليس: شقوه بالمنشار شقا. قال فشققت مع الشجرة بالمنشار قال له النبى صلى الله عليه وسلم: هل وجدت له مسا أو وجعا قال لا إنما وجدت ذلك الشجرة التى جعل الله روحي فيها.

“The Children of Israel said: The God of Zakariya has become angry with him, so come, let us become angry for the sake of our king and kill Zakariya. They began searching for me to kill me. A man informed me of this, so I fled. Iblis was walking ahead of those people and was telling them about me. When I feared that I would not be able to escape any further, a tree came in front of me and said: Come to me. Saying this, its trunk spread out. I began to enter it. In the meantime, Iblis came and grabbed a corner of my cloak. Suddenly the trunk of the tree closed and the corner of my cloak remained outside the tree. When the Children of Israel arrived, Iblis said to them: Do you not see that Zakariya has entered this tree through his sorcery? Here is the corner of his cloak! The Children of Israel said that they would burn this tree. Iblis said: Cut it apart with a saw. Thus I was sawn apart along with the tree. The Prophet ﷺ asked Sayyidna Zakariya (peace be upon him): Did you suffer any harm or pain from this? Sayyidna Zakariya (peace be upon him) said: No, I only felt as if Allah had placed my soul into that very tree.”

Reference: Tarikh Dimashq by Ibn Asakir: 56/19

But this is a fabricated narration. The responsibility for fabricating it lies with Ishaq bin Bishr bin Muhammad bin Abdullah, Abu Hudhayfa, al-Bukhari, who is a “matruk” (abandoned) and “kadhdhab” (liar) narrator.

Reference: See: Mizan al-I’tidal by al-Dhahabi: 184/1-186

Similar incidents attributed to Sayyidna Zakariya (peace be upon him) have also been reported from some Tabi’in. Let us also examine the status of the narrations from them:

The narration of Sa’id bin al-Musayyab

Reference: Tarikh Dimashq: 207/64

In it, the narrator Ali bin Zayd bin Jud’an is “da’if” (weak).

The narration of Wahb bin Munabbih

Reference: Tarikh Dimashq: 55/19

In it, the narrator Abd al-Mun’im bin Idris is present, who, by the consensus of the muhaddithun, is “matruk” and “kadhdhab”. Moreover, his father Idris bin Sinan, Abu al-Ilyas al-San’ani, is also “da’if”.

Similarly, the narration reported by Muhammad bin Ishaq bin Yasar

Reference: Tarikh al-Tabari: 536/1

This is “da’if” due to the unreliability of Muhammad bin Humayd al-Razi.

It is thus established that the claim spread by some people that Sayyidna Zakariya (peace be upon him) sought refuge in a tree is a blatant lie.