Acceptance Criteria for Sufyan al-Thawri’s ‘An’ Narrations: A Detailed Evidence-Based Study

اردو میں پڑھیں
Font size:
Source: Fatawa Ilmiyyah (Tawzeeḥ al-Aḥkām), Volume 2, Page 312

Question

Is the tadlīs (concealment) of Sufyan al-Thawri accepted or not accepted? Please answer with evidence.

Answer

الحمد لله، والصلاة والسلام علىٰ رسول الله، أما بعد!

The following detailed research is presented regarding Imam Sufyan al-Thawri, may Allah have mercy on him:

(1) The trustworthiness and reliability of Sufyan al-Thawri, may Allah have mercy on him

◈ Imam Sufyan al-Thawri, may Allah have mercy on him, is unanimously considered trustworthy and reliable.
◈ His authentication has been made by Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Al-Ajli, Al-Daraqutni, Ibn Hibban, and others.
◈ Imam Nasai, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
> “He is above being called trustworthy; in my opinion, he was one of the leaders among the pious Imams.”
◈ Imam Shu’bah, may Allah have mercy on him, described him as “Amir al-Mu’minin fi al-Hadith”.

Reference: Tahdhib al-Kamal by Al-Mizzi (Volume 7, Page 360)

◈ The hadiths narrated by him are found in the Six Books and other common hadith collections.

(2) The tadlīs (concealment) practiced by Sufyan al-Thawri, may Allah have mercy on him

◈ There is Ijma’ (consensus) that Sufyan al-Thawri, may Allah have mercy on him, used to practice tadlīs.

Statements of various muhaddithin:

◈ Hashim bin Bashir (died 183 AH) said to Abdullah bin Al-Mubarak:

> ’’ان کبیریک قد دلّسا: الاعمش و سفیان‘‘

> Meaning both your elders, Al-A’mash and Sufyan (Thawri), used to practice tadlees (concealment).

Reference: Al-Kamil by Ibn Adi (Vol. 7, p. 2596), Al-‘Ilal Al-Kabir by Al-Tirmidhi (Vol. 2, p. 966), Ilmi Maqalat (Vol. 1, p. 251)

(All chains authentic)

◈ Yahya bin Ma’in said:

> ’’وکان یدلس‘‘

> Meaning Sufyan Thawri used to practice tadlees.

Reference: Al-Jarh wa Al-Ta’dil (Vol. 4, p. 325), Al-Kifayah by Al-Khatib (p. 361)

(Chains authentic)

◈ Sufyan Thawri’s student Abu ‘Asim Al-Nabil said:

Reference: > ’’نری ان سفیان الثوری انما دلسه عن ابی حنیفة‘‘
Sunan Al-Daraqutni (Vol. 3, p. 201, Hadith 3423)

◈ Imam Bukhari says:

> ’’اعلم الناس بالثوری یحیی بن سعید، لانه عرف صحیح حدیثه من تدلیسه‘‘

> Meaning the one who knew Sufyan the most was Yahya bin Sa’id Al-Qattan because he recognized the authentic hadiths among his tadlees.

Reference: Al-Kamil by Ibn Adi (Vol. 1, p. 111)

(Chain authentic)

◈ Yahya Al-Qattan’s narration from Sufyan Thawri is considered based on hearing.

Reference: Nur Al-‘Aynayn (2nd edition, p. 124)

◈ Imam Ali bin al-Madini’s statement:

> ’’والناس یحتاجون فی حدیث سفیان الی یحیی القطان، الحال الاخبار یعنی علی: ان سفیان کان یدلس و ان یحیی القطان کان یوقفه علی ما سمع مما لم یسمع‘‘

> Meaning, people were dependent on Yahya al-Qattan regarding the hadiths of Sufyan, because he clarified the difference between Sufyan’s explicitly transmitted and non-explicitly transmitted narrations.

Reference: Al-Kifayah (page 362)

(Authentic chain)

✅ From all this detail, it becomes clear that Sufyan al-Thawri being a mudallis (one who conceals defects in the chain) is a matter of consensus.

First Warning:

◈ Hafiz Suyuti wrote in “Tadrib al-Rawi”:

> ’’روی البیهقی فی المدخل عن محمد بن رافع قال: قلت لابی عامر: کان الثوری یدلس؟ قال: لا………الخ‘‘

> Meaning, according to Abu Amir, Sufyan al-Thawri did not practice tadlis (concealment).

But this narration is rejected for several reasons:
➊ This reference is not found in Imam Bayhaqi’s book Al-Madkhal.
➋ Suyuti did not mention the chain from Bayhaqi to Muhammad bin Rafi’.
➌ It is not clear whether Suyuti quoted the phrase directly from Al-Madkhal or from another source.
➍ Compared to the mutawatir statements of the muhaddithin (hadith scholars), this narration is anomalous (shadh), therefore it is not acceptable.

Second Warning:

◈ The author of Raqim al-Huroof wrote in Noor al-Aynain about Sufyan al-Thawri:
> “Hafiz al-Alai’s Kaldi mentioned him in the second category before Hafiz Ibn Hajar.”

Reference: (Old edition page 102, new edition page 127)

This statement is incorrect, from which I retract.

🔄 Correct reference:
> “Imam Hakim mentioned him in the second category (third type) before Hafiz Ibn Hajar.”

Reference: Jami’ al-Tahsil page 99, Ma’rifat ‘Uloom al-Hadith by Hakim page 106

📌 This makes it clear that it is the statement of Imam Hakim, which was mistakenly attributed to Hafiz Alai.
This statement supports the position that Sufyan al-Thawri should be counted in the third category.

Statements of Hanafi Jurists:

◈ Ayni Hanafi writes:

> ’’وسفیان من المدلسین و المدلس لا یحتج بعنعنته الا ان یثبت سماعه من طریق آخر‘‘

> Meaning Sufyan is among the mudallisīn (those who practice tadlis), and his ‘an’ narration is not authoritative until it is confirmed by hearing from another chain.

Reference: Umdat al-Qari (Vol. 3, page 112, chapter on Wudu without Hadath)

Tadlis from weak narrators:

◈ Sufyan al-Thawri also practiced tadlis from weak narrators.

Reference: Mizan al-I’tidal (Vol. 2, page 169, translation 3322)

Fundamental principle:

◈ Abu Bakr Al-Sir in his book “Ad-Dala’il” writes:

> ’’کل من ظهر تدلیسه عن غیر الثقات لم یقبل خبره حتی یقول حدثنی او سمعت‘‘

> That is, a narrator who practices tadlis from a non-trustworthy person, his narration is not accepted until he uses the words “hadathani” or “sami’tu”.

Reference: Sharh Alfiya Al-Iraqi / At-Tabassur wa At-Tadhakkur (Vol. 1, pages 184, 185), Ilmi Maqalat (Vol. 1, page 251)

Statements of Imam Hakim and Imam Ibn Hibban:

◈ From this, it is understood that Sufyan Thawri, may Allah have mercy on him, is among the third category of mudallis.
◈ Imam Hakim’s statement is also supported by the writing of Hafiz Ibn Hibban:

> ’’واما المدلسون الذین هم ثقات و عدول فانا لا تحتج باخبارهم الا ما بینوا السماع فیما رووا مثل الثوری والاعمش وابی اسحاق و اضرابهم‘‘

> That is, mudallis who are trustworthy and just (such as Sufyan Thawri, A’mash, Abu Ishaq, and others), only those narrations of theirs are taken as proof in which they explicitly mention “sama'” (hearing).

Reference: Al-Ihsan (Vol. 1, page 92), Verified Manuscript (Vol. 1, page 161)

Conclusion:

The narration from Sufyan Thawri through ‘an’ is accepted only when it explicitly mentions “sama'”. Otherwise, his narration through ‘an’ is not accepted.

Reference: For detailed study: Nur Al-‘Aynayn, Ilmi Maqalat (Vol. 1, page 251)