Toggle above to switch between keyword search and direct hadith lookup
مصنف ابن ابي شيبه
Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah
كتاب الفرائضBook of Inheritance
في أم وأخت لأب وأم وجدRegarding the Case of Husband, Mother, Sister, and Grandfather, Known as the 'Akdariyyah' Issue
Hadith 33352
اُردوEn
٣٣٣٥٢ - قال وكيع: وقال الشعبي: سألني الحجاج بن يوسف عنها فأخبرته بأقاويلهم فأعجبه قول علي، فقال: قول من هذا؟ (فقلت) (١): قول أبي تراب، (ففطن) (٢) الحجاج فقال: إنا لم نعب على (علي) (٣) قضاءه، إنما عبنا كذا وكذا (٤).
33352 - Waki‘ said: And al-Sha‘bi said: Al-Hajjaj ibn Yusuf asked me about it, so I informed him of their statements, and he was pleased with the saying of ‘Ali. He said: Whose saying is this? (I said): The saying of Abu Turab. (Al-Hajjaj realized) and said: We did not criticize (‘Ali) (3) for his judgment, we only criticized such and such (4).
