• 🌟 Support the Mission of Spreading Authentic Islamic Knowledge 🌟

    Tohed.com is dedicated to sharing the pure teachings of Islam based on the Qur’an & Sunnah.

    📦 Your donation = Sadaqah Jariyah!

    “The most beloved of deeds to Allah are those that are most consistent, even if small.” – Bukhari

Understanding the Hadith on Camel Urine: Context and Clarifications

✿ Hadith on Camel Urine as a Cure: Context and Objections​


◈ Text of the Hadith and the Objection​


A Hadith recorded in Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī mentions that the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ advised a group of sick individuals to drink camel milk and urine as a form of treatment.
(Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī: Bāb al-Dawāʾ, Bāb Bawāl al-Ibil)


This narration has become the subject of criticism, where objectors question how the Prophet ﷺ could prescribe the drinking of something impure such as urine. Christian missionaries and atheists often present this narration mockingly, as though drinking camel urine is an obligatory practice for all Muslims. Some critics also attempt to equate this with Hindu religious practices involving the consumption of cow urine.


This article presents a detailed analysis of the authenticity, ruling, and responses to the objections surrounding this narration.

◈ Authenticity of the Hadith​


According to the scholars of Hadith and leading Islamic jurists, this narration is completely authentic. No reliable Hadith scholar has questioned its authenticity.


Furthermore, this narration is not only found in Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, but is also reported in numerous other Hadith collections with multiple chains of transmission, making it credible from a sanad (chain of narration) perspective.

◈ Opinions of the Jurists: Treatment with Camel Milk and Urine​


✔ A Unique Incident​


This incident occurred only once during the lifetime of the Prophet ﷺ, and there is no recorded instance of such a treatment being prescribed again by any Companion or Successor. Scholars have provided different interpretations to clarify the context of this Hadith.


◈ Imām Abū Ḥanīfah’s (رحمه الله) Perspective​


According to Imām Abū Ḥanīfah, the Prophet ﷺ, through Divine knowledge, became aware that the healing for those specific individuals was found in that particular remedy.


Thus, the incident is categorized under exceptional or emergency circumstances (iḍṭirār), where the use of otherwise unlawful or impure substances is permitted. As stated in the Qur’an:


"But whoever is forced by necessity, neither desiring it nor transgressing limits, there is no sin upon him..."
(Surah al-Baqarah: 173)


Hence, this directive was not general, but issued for a specific situation. It is not mandatory for any Muslim to adopt such treatment.


◈ Timeframe and Abrogation of the Ruling​


The study of Hadith indicates that this incident occurred before the sixth year after Hijrah. According to Qatādah (رحمه الله), the incident took place prior to the revelation of the rulings on legal punishments (ḥudūd).


Following this, such methods were no longer used, and the Prophet ﷺ never recommended such a treatment again.


◈ Comparison with Hindu Practice of Cow Urine​


Fundamental Differences


Religious Sanctity of Cow Urine:
In Hinduism, drinking cow urine is considered a form of sanctity and worship.
In contrast, Islam does not consider camel urine sacred in any form.


Purpose of Camel Urine in Islam:
In Islam, the mention of camel urine is strictly for medical purposes in a one-time exceptional case, and it has never been associated with religious rituals or beliefs.

Principle of Ease in Islam


Islam allows the use of impure or prohibited substances in specific emergency situations, especially for the purpose of treatment.


Even today, thousands of medications contain ingredients derived from impure or unlawful sources, yet their use is considered permissible if it serves a legitimate medical purpose.


✅ Summary​


The narration found in Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī regarding the use of camel urine for treatment is an exceptional case, permitted under emergency conditions.


It is not a part of general Islamic rulings or prophetic practices (sunnah). Nowhere does the Hadith state that such treatment is obligatory for Muslims.


The objections raised are based on ignorance or deliberate misrepresentation.
Islam’s guiding principle has always been to create ease and allowance in times of necessity.


➤ Key Takeaway:
This Hadith represents a specific and exceptional allowance, not a general religious prescription.
 
Back
Top