Sayyiduna Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is the son-in-law of the Messenger, the fourth caliph and the Lion of Allah. Many virtues and merits came to him from the tongue of prophethood. Whatever has reached us about Sayyiduna Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) from the Messenger of Allah ﷺ with an authentic chain is his true virtue and merit. Bundles of material based on fabricated, “munkar” (rejected) and “da’if” (weak) narrations can in no way attain the status of virtues and merits. We are mentioning one such statement here:
أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها
“I am the city of knowledge and Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is its door.”
It is well known among the common people that this is a noble saying of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, but in reality it is not so, because according to the principles of the hadith scholars this narration does not reach the level of authenticity. To know its standing as evidence, see the detailed research on all the narrations reported on this subject:
Narration number: ➊
It is attributed to Sayyiduna Ali bin Abi Talib (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا دار الحكمة، وعلي بابها
“I am the house of wisdom and Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is its door.”
Comment:
The chain of this narration is “da’if” (weak), because:
➊ It contains the narrator Muhammad bin Umar bin Abdullah al-Rumi, who is “da’if” (weak) according to the majority of hadith scholars, as:
◈ Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
فيه ضعف. “There is weakness in him.”
◈ Imam Abu Zur’ah al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
شيخ لين . “He is a weak narrator.”
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
يقلب الـأخبار، ويأتي من الثقات بما ليس من أحاديثهم، لا يجوز الاحتجاج به بحال
“He turns hadiths upside down and attributes to trustworthy narrators what is not from their hadiths; it is not permissible to use his narration as evidence in any case.”
Remember that Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) mentioned this criticism by mistake in the biography of the father of Muhammad bin Umar, and mentioned Muhammad bin Umar in al-Thiqat
.
◈ In this regard, Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) writes:
غلط ابن حبان فلينه، وانما اللين ابنه محمد بن عمر
“Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) made a mistake and declared Umar bin Abdullah weak; in reality it is his son Muhammad bin Umar who is the weak narrator.”
◈ Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) has also declared his hadith weak.
➋ It also contains the narrator Sharik bin Abdullah, about whom:
◈ Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
صدوق يخطئ كثيرا، تغير حفظه منذ ولي القضاء بالكوفة
“He was truthful, but made very many mistakes. His memory deteriorated from the time he became judge of Kufa.”
↰ It has not been established by any evidence that Muhammad bin Umar al-Rumi narrated hadiths from Sharik bin Abdullah the judge before his memory deteriorated.
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
كان فى آخر أمره يخطئ فيما يروي، تغير عليه حفظه، فسماع المتقدمين عنه؛ الذين سمعوا منه بواسط، ليس فيه تخليط، مثل يزيد بن هارون، وإسحاق الـأزرق، وسماع المتأخرين عنه بالكوفة؛ فيه أوهام كثيرة
“In the last part of his life, there are mistakes in the narrations related by Sharik bin Abdullah, because his memory had deteriorated. As for his earliest students who heard from him in the region of Wasit, such as Yazid bin Harun and Ishaq al-Azraq, the deterioration of memory has no effect on their narrations. But the later students who heard from him in Kufa, there are countless errors in the narrations they related.”
↰ Sharik bin Abdullah the judge was born in 95 AH and died in 177 AH. He was appointed judge of Wasit in 150 AH. Later, after the death of Abu Ja’far al-Mansur, he became judge of Kufa. Abu Ja’far al-Mansur died in 158 AH, and Muhammad bin Umar al-Rumi died around 220 AH. This makes a gap of about 62 years. From this it appears that Muhammad bin Umar al-Rumi, who is himself a “da’if” (weak) narrator, heard narrations from Sharik the judge after his memory had deteriorated.
➌ It also contains the “tadlis” (concealment) of Sharik bin Abdullah the judge.
↰ This is why the scholars have explicitly declared this narration false, baseless and “munkar” (rejected), as:
◈ Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) said that this hadith is “munkar” (rejected).
◈ After reporting this narration, Imam al-Tirmidhi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
هذا حديث غريب منكر “This hadith is gharib and munkar.”
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
هٰذا خبر لا أصل له عن النبى صلى اللہ عليه وسلم .
“This narration is not established from the Prophet ﷺ.”
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
فما أدري من وضعه . “I do not know who fabricated it.”
——————
Narration number: ➋
It is attributed to Sayyiduna Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) as well that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: أنا دار الحكمة، وعلي بابها، (زاد الـآجري 🙂 فمن أراد أتاها من بابها . “I am the house of wisdom and Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is its door. Imam al-Ajurri (may Allah have mercy on him) added these words to this narration: Whoever wishes to come to this house, let him come through its door.”
Sayyiduna Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) used to say: إن بين أضلاعي لعلما كثيرا “Between my ribs (in my heart) there is a great deal of knowledge.”
Research:
The condition of the chain of this narration is the same as that of the chain mentioned above.
——————
Narration number: ➌
It is narrated from Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم؛ فليأت باب المدينة .
“I am the city of knowledge and Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is its door, so whoever intends to acquire knowledge, let him come to the door of the city.”
Comment:
This chain of narration is defective for several reasons, because it contains:
➊ the tadlis (concealment of a defect in the chain) of Sharik bin Abdullah, the judge.
➋ Salamah bin Kuhayl did not hear from al-Sunabihi.
Regarding Suwayd bin Sa’id al-Hadathani:
◈ Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
موصوف بالتدليس؛ وصفه الدارقطني والإسماعيلي وغيرهما، وقد تغير فى آخر عمره بسبب العمي، فضعف بسبب ذٰلك .
“He is described as practising tadlis; Imam al-Daraqutni, Imam al-Isma’ili and others have called him a mudallis. Because of blindness, his memory also changed in the last part of his life, and for this reason he was judged weak (da’if).”
——————
Narration number: ➍
It is narrated from Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) himself that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة الفقه، وعلي بابها
“I am the city of fiqh and Ali is its door.”
Comment:
This is a false chain of narration; several defects are found in it:
➊ The narrator Abd al-Hamid bin Bahr al-Basri is accused of stealing hadiths.
◈ Regarding him, Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
ولعبد الحميد هٰذا غير حديث منكر، رواه وسرقه من قوم ثقات
“Several hadiths narrated by this Abd al-Hamid are munkar (rejected); he narrated them by stealing them from trustworthy narrators.”
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يروي عن مالك وشريك والكوفيين ما ليس من أحاديثهم، وكان يسرق الحديث، لا يحل الاحتجاج به بحال
“He narrates from Malik, Sharik and the Kufans hadiths that they never narrated. He used to steal hadiths. It is not permissible in any case to take his narration as evidence.”
◈ Imam al-Hakim (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يروي عن مالك بن مغول وشريك أحاديث مقلوبة
“He used to narrate maqlub (reversed) hadiths from Malik bin Mighwal and Sharik.”
◈ Imam Abu Nu’aym al-Isbahani (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يروي عن مالك وشريك أحاديث منكرة
“He narrates munkar hadiths from Malik and Sharik.”
➋ There is also the tadlis of Sharik bin Abdullah, the judge.
◈ Regarding this narration, the Dhahabi of his age, Allamah al-Mu’allimi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
وإن المروي عن شريك لا يثبت عنه، ولو ثبت لم يتحصل منه علٰي شيئ لتدليس شريك وخطئه، والاضطراب الذى لا يوثق منه علٰي شيئ
“Indeed this narration is not established from Sharik. Even if it were hypothetically established, nothing would be gained from it, because it also contains the tadlis of Sharik, his error and idtirab (inconsistency), because of which he cannot be relied upon in anything.”
——————
Narration number: ➎
It is attributed to Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة الجنة، وأنت بابها يا علي، كذب من زعم أنه يدخلها من غير بابها .
“I am the city of Paradise, and you, O Ali (may Allah be pleased with him), are its door. Whoever claims that he will enter this city from anywhere other than the door is lying.”
Comment:
Its chain of narration is false, because:
➊ Regarding the narrator Sa’d bin Tarif al-Iskafi, Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
متروك ورماه ابن حبان بالوضع، وكان رافضيا
“He is a matruk (abandoned) narrator; Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) accused him of fabrication. He was a Rafidi.”
➋ Regarding Asbagh bin Nubatah al-Tamimi, Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
متروك، رمي بالرفض
“He is a matruk (abandoned) narrator; the hadith scholars called him a Rafidi.”
——————
Narration number: ➏
It is narrated from Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) himself that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
شجرة أنا أصلها، وعلي فرعها، والحسن والحسين من ثمرها، والشيعة ورقها، فهل يخرج من الطيب إلا الطيب؟ وأنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، فمن أرادها؛ فليأت الباب
“I am the trunk of a tree, Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is its branch, Hasan and Husayn (may Allah be pleased with them both) are its fruit, and the Shia are its leaves. Nothing but what is pure comes out of what is pure. I am the city of knowledge and Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is its door, so whoever intends to enter the city, let him come to its door.”
Comment:
Its chain of narration is also false and fabricated, because:
◈ Imam al-Khatib al-Baghdadi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يحيي بن بشارنالكندي الكوفي حدث عن إسماعيل بن إبراهيم الهمداني، وجميعا مجهولان
“Yahya bin Bishar al-Kindi, al-Kufi narrated this from Isma’il bin Ibrahim al-Hamdani, and both of them are majhul (unknown).”
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يحيي بن بشارن الكندي لا يعرف عن مثله، وأتٰي بخبر مباطل
“Yahya bin Bishar al-Kindi is an unknown narrator. He narrated a false report.”
——————
Narration number: ➐
It is narrated from Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة الحكمة، وأنت ـ يا علي ـ بابها
“I am the city of wisdom, and you, O Ali (may Allah be pleased with him), are its door.”
Comment:
This is an extremely false narration, because:
➊ The narrator Jabir bin Yazid al-Ju’fi is a liar and “matruk (abandoned)”.
➋ Regarding Ahmad bin Hammad al-Hamdani, Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
لا أعرف ذا “I do not know who this is.”
➌ The narrator Amr bin Shamir is “da’if (weak)” and “matruk (abandoned)”.
There are other defects in this chain of narration as well.
——————
Narration number: ➑
It is attributed to Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم؛ فليأت الباب
“I am the city of knowledge and Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is its door, so whoever intends to acquire knowledge, let him come to the door of the city.”
Commentary:
This too is a false narration, because Hafiz Ibn al-Jawzi (may Allah have mercy on him) did not mention the chain from Imam Ibn Mardawayh up to Husayn ibn Ali (may Allah be pleased with them both); rather, after mentioning it, he himself says:
“There are several unknown narrators in its chain.”
——————
Narration No.: ➒
It is attributed to Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
يا علي، أنا مدينة العلم، وأنت الباب، كذب من زعم أنه يصل إلى المدينة، إلا من الباب
“O Ali! I am the city of knowledge and you are its door. Whoever claims that he will enter the city from anywhere other than this door is lying.”
Commentary:
The chain of this narration is also false:
➊ Nothing is known about the narrator Muhammad ibn Abdullah ibn Umar ibn Muslim al-Lahiqi.
➋ The narrator Muhammad ibn Abdullah ibn Muhammad Abu al-Mufaddal al-Kufi is an extreme liar, an impostor (dajjal), and a fabricator of false hadiths.
——————
Narration No.: ➓
It is attributed to Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم؛ فليأت الباب
“I am the city of knowledge and Ali is its door, so whoever intends to seek knowledge should come through the door of the city.”
Commentary:
Its chain is also false, because:
➊ Regarding Dawud ibn Sulayman al-Jurjani al-Ghazi, Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
كذبه يحيي بن معين، ولم يعرفه أبو حاتم، وبكل حال؛ فهو شيخ كذاب، له نسخة موضوعة عن على بن موسي الرضٰي، رواها على بن محمد بن مهرويه القزويني الصدوق عنه
“Imam Yahya ibn Ma’in (may Allah have mercy on him) called him a liar (kadhdhab). Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) declared him unknown (majhul). In any case, he is a lying narrator. He had a copy consisting of fabricated narrations through the chain of Ali ibn Musa al-Rida, which Ali ibn Muhammad ibn Mahrawayh al-Qazwini, a truthful (saduq) narrator, transmitted from him.”
➋ Regarding Ali ibn Husayn ibn Bundar ibn Muthanna al-Astarabadhi;
◈ Hamzah ibn Yusuf al-Sahmi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
تكلم فيه الناس “The scholars of hadith have criticised him.”
◈ Ibn al-Najjar (may Allah have mercy on him) declared him “da’if (weak)”.
◈ Ibn Tahir declared him “accused (muttaham)”.
——————
Narration No.: ⓫
It is narrated from Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم؛ فليأت الباب
“I am the city of knowledge and Ali is its door, so whoever wants to seek knowledge should come through the door of the city.”
Commentary:
This too is a false narration, because:
➊ Nothing could be found out about the narrator Hasan ibn Muhammad ibn Jarir.
➋ An introduction to Ubaydullah ibn Abi Rafi’ is also required.
——————
Narration No.: ⓬
It is narrated from Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، ولا تؤتي البيوت إلا من أبوابها
“I am the city of knowledge and Ali is its door. Houses are entered only through their doors.”
Commentary:
This narration is also not established, because:
➊ Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) called Ali ibn Umar ibn Ali ibn Husayn “mastur (of unknown status)”.
➋ Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) declared Hafs ibn Umar al-San’ani “da’if (weak)”.
➌ Muhammad ibn Musaffa ibn Bahlul al-Qurashi is guilty of “tadlis al-taswiyah (concealing a weak narrator between two reliable ones)”.
——————
Narration No.: ⓭
There is also a narration in the book of Imam al-Daraqutni (may Allah have mercy on him)
.
◈ Regarding its narrator Yahya ibn Salamah ibn Kuhayl, Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
متروك، وكان شيعيا “He is a matruk (abandoned) narrator and a Shi’i.”
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) also called him “matruk (abandoned)”.
——————
Narration No.: ⓮
It is attributed to Jabir ibn Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him) that on the occasion of Hudaybiyyah, the Messenger of Allah ﷺ took hold of the arm of Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) and said:
هٰذا أمير البررة، وقاتل الفجرة، منصور من نصره، مخذول من خذله‘، مد بها صوته، ثم قال : ’أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد الحكم؛ فليأت الباب
“This is the leader of the righteous and the slayer of the wicked. Whoever helps him will be victorious, and whoever tries to humiliate him will himself be humiliated. The Prophet ﷺ spoke these words in a raised voice. Then he said: I am the city of knowledge and Ali is its door, so whoever intends to acquire wisdom should come through the door of the city.”
Commentary:
This too is a false narration, because in it:
➊ The narrator Ahmad bin Abdullah bin Yazid al-Hushaymi is a liar and a fabricator of false narrations. Concerning him:
◈ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يضع الحديث
“He fabricates it himself and attributes it to the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.”
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يروي عن عبد الرزاق والثقات الـأوابد والطامات
“He narrates rejected and false narrations from Imam Abd al-Razzaq and other trustworthy people.”
◈ Imam al-Daraqutni (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
يروي عن عبد الرزاق وغيره بالمناكير، يترك حديثه
“He narrates rejected narrations from Imam Abd al-Razzaq (may Allah have mercy on him) and other narrators; his hadith has been declared abandoned.”
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) has called him a liar.
◈ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) declares these words fabricated and false, saying:
هٰذا حديث منكر موضوع
“This hadith is munkar (rejected) and fabricated.”
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
وهٰذا شيئ مقلوب إسناده ومتنه معا
“Both the chain of narration and the text of this narration are reversed (maqlub).”
◈ The tadlis (concealment) of Imam Sufyan al-Thawri is also present.
↰ When Imam al-Hakim (may Allah have mercy on him)
declared its chain of narration “sahih (authentic)”, Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) said in refutation of him and in response:
العجب من الحاكم وجرأته فى تصحيحه هٰذا وأمثاله من البواطيل، أحمد هٰذا دجال كذاب
“It is astonishing of Imam al-Hakim, how he dared to declare this narration and other false narrations like it sahih! Although in its chain of narration Ahmad bin Abdullah is a deceiver and a liar.”
◈ In another place Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
بل ـ واللہ ـ موضوع، وأحمد كذاب، فما أجهلك علٰي سعة معرفتك
“By Allah! This is a fabricated narration; the narrator Ahmad in it is a liar. Despite the breadth of your knowledge, how unaware you remained of this.”
Remember that the narrator Ahmad bin Abdullah bin Yazid has a corroboration (mutaba’ah) by Ahmad bin Tahir bin Harmala al-Tujibi al-Misri, but it is of no benefit, because al-Tujibi is also a lying narrator.
For this reason, Hafiz Ibn al-Jawzi (may Allah have mercy on him) says about this narration:
لا يصح من جميع الوجوه
“With all the chains of narration, this narration is weak.”
——————
Narration number: ⓯
It is attributed to Abu Sa’id al-Khudri (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
علي بن أبي طالب عليه السلام سيد العرب، فقيل ألست أنت سيد العرب؟ فقال : أنا سيد ولد آدم، وعلي سيد العرب، من أحبه وتولاه؛ أحبه اللہ وهداه، ومن أبغضه وعاداه؛ أصمه اللہ وأعماه، علي؛ حقه كحقي، وطاعته كطاعتي، غير أنه لا نبي بعدي، من فارقه فارقني، ومن فارقني؛ فارقه اللہ، أنا مدينة الحكمة، وهى الجنة، وعلي بابها، فكيف يهتدي المهتدي إلى الجنة إلا من بابها، على عليه السلام خير البشر، من أبٰي فقد كفر
“Ali bin Abi Talib is the master of the Arabs. It was said to him ﷺ: Are you ﷺ not the master of the Arabs? He ﷺ said: I am the master of the children of Adam, and Ali is the master of the Arabs. Whoever takes him as a friend, Allah, the Lord of Honour, will love him and guide him. Whoever harbours hatred for him, Allah will be hostile to him and will make him blind and deaf. His right is like my right, and obedience to him is in reality obedience to me, except that there is no prophet after me. Whoever separates from him has in reality separated from me, and whoever distanced himself from me, Allah will remove him far from His mercy. I am the city of wisdom, that is, of Paradise, and Ali is its door. How would anyone reach Paradise without passing through this door? Ali is better than all human beings; whoever denies this has certainly become a disbeliever.”
Commentary:
This is a false narration, because:
➊ Isa bin Mihran Abu Musa al-Musta’tif, the narrator, is a liar.
Concerning him:
◈ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
حدث بأحاديث موضوعة مناكير، محترق فى الرفض
“He narrates fabricated and rejected narrations and is a staunch Rafidi.”
◈ Imam al-Khatib al-Baghdadi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
كان عيسي بن مهران المستعطف من شياطين الرافضة ومردتهم، ووقع إلى كتاب من تصنيفه فى الطعن على الصحابة وتضليلهم وإكفارهم وتفسيقهم، فواللہ لقد قف شعري عند نظري فيه، وعظم تعجبي مما أودع ذٰلك الكتاب من الـأحاديث الموضوعة، والـأقاصيص المختلقة، والـأنبائ المفتعلة، بالـأسانيد المظلمة، عن سقاط الكوفيين، من المعروفين بالكذب، ومن المجهولين، ودلني ذٰلك علٰي عمي بصيرة واضعه، وخبث سريرة جامعه، وخيبة سعي طالبه، واحتقاب وزر كاتبه، {فويل لهم مما كتبت ايديهم وويل لهم مما يكسبون}، {وسيعلم الذين ظلموا اي منقلب ينقلبون}
“Isa bin Mihran al-Musta’tif is a devil and a rebellious Rafidi. He compiled a book in which he slandered the noble Companions and declared them (Allah forbid) misguided, disbelievers and sinners. By Allah! When I looked at this book, my hair stood on end. I was greatly astonished to see in this book fabricated narrations, invented stories and self-made tales. The chains of narration of these narrations are dark, and are reported from well-known lying Kufans and unknown narrators. These things point to Isa bin Mihran’s blind insight, his corrupt inner self, his failed effort and the ruin of his Hereafter. These words of the Exalted Lord apply to him: فويل لهم مما كتبت ايديهم وويل لهم مما يكسبون
, ‘Woe to them for what their hands have written, and woe to them for what they earn.’ وسيعلم الذين ظلموا اي منقلب ينقلبون
‘Those who have wronged will soon know to what turn they will be turned back.'”
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
رافضي، كذاب جبل “He was a Rafidi and a great liar.”
➋ Its narrator Muhammad bin Abdullah bin Ubaydullah bin Muhammad bin Abdullah bin Muhammad bin Ubaydullah, Abu al-Fadl al-Kufi, is also an extreme liar, a deceiver and a fabricator of false hadiths. See:
➌ Concerning its narrator Khalid bin Tahman Abu al-Ala al-Khaffaf, Imam Yahya bin Ma’in (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
وخلط خالد الخفاف قبل موته بعشر سنين، وكان قبل ذٰلك ثقة، وكان فى تخليطه كل ما جائ وه به ورآه؛ قرأه
“Khalid al-Khaffaf fell into confusion of memory (ikhtilat) ten years before his death. Before that he was trustworthy, but after the confusion he began to accept prompting (talqin).”
➍ The author of the book, Ibn Shadhan, was also an extreme liar; detailed discussion about him is to come in the coming lines.
——————
Narration number: ⓯
It is attributed to Sayyiduna Abdullah ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
يا علي، أنا مدينة الحكمة، وأنت بابها، وما تؤتي المدينة إلا من قبل الباب، وكذب من زعم أنه يحبني ويبغضك؛ لأنك مني وأنا منك، لحمك من لحمي، ودمك من دمي، وروحك من روحي، وسريرتك من سريرتي، وعلانيتك من علانيتي، وأنت إمام أمتي، وخليفتي عليها بعدي، سعد من أطاعك، وشقي من عصاك، وربح من تولاك، وخسر من عاداك، وفاز من لزمك، وخسر من فارقك، فمثلك ومثل الـأئمة من ولدك بعدي؛ مثل سفينة نوح عليه السلام، من ركبها نجا، ومن تخلف عنها غرق، ومثلكم مثل النجوم؛ كلما غاب نجم طلع نجم، إلٰي يوم القيامة
“O Ali! I am the city of wisdom and you are its door. Whoever wants to enter this city will enter only through the door. Whoever claims to love me while hating you is a liar in his claim of love for me, because you are from me and I am from you. Your flesh is from my flesh, your blood is from my blood, your soul is from my soul, your inner self is from my inner self, and your outward self is from my outward self. You are the imam of my Ummah and my successor over the Ummah of Muhammad after me. Fortunate is the one who obeys you and wretched is the one who disobeys you. He who befriends you will profit, and he who is hostile to you will suffer loss. Success lies in your companionship and loss lies in separation from you. After me, the example of you and the imams from your offspring is like the Ark of Nuh: whoever boarded it was saved, and whoever stayed behind from boarding it was drowned. Your example is like that of the stars: when one star sets, another rises. It will remain like this until the Day of Resurrection.”
Commentary:
This narration is a bundle of lies, because:
➊ Concerning the narrator Sa’d ibn Tarif al-Iskafi al-Khaffaf, this statement of Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) has been mentioned before:
متروك، ورماه ابن حبان بالوضع، وكان رافضيا
“He is a matruk (abandoned) narrator. Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) accused him of fabricating hadiths. He was also a Rafidi.”
➋ The author of the book, Muhammad ibn Ahmad ibn Ali ibn Husayn ibn Shadhan, is a deceiver and a liar. Concerning him:
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
ولقد ساق أخطب خوارزم من طريق هٰذا الدجال؛ ابن شاذان أحاديث كثيرة باطلة سمجة ركيكة، فى مناقب السيد على رضي اللہ عنه
“Akhtab Khwarazm related, through the chain of this deceiver Ibn Shadhan, many false, baseless and incredible narrations about the virtues of Sayyiduna Ali (may Allah be pleased with him).”
He also says about one narration reported by him:
هٰذا كذب “This is a lie.”
——————
Narration number: ⓲
It is attributed to Sayyiduna Abdullah ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم؛ فليأت الباب
“I am the city of knowledge and Ali is its door. Whoever intends to seek knowledge should come through the door.”
Commentary:
This too is a fabricated narration, because:
➊ Concerning Ahmad ibn Hafs al-Sa’di:
◈ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
حدث بأحاديث منكرة لم يتابع عليه
“He narrated rejected hadiths on which he was not corroborated.”
◈ Imam al-Isma’ili (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
ممرور، يكون أحيانا أشبه
“His mind had gone. Sometimes confusion would befall him.”
◈ Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) says in explanation of this statement:
فأشار إلٰي أنه أحيانا يغيب عقله، والممرور الذى يصيبه الخلط من المرة، فيخلط
“Imam al-Isma’ili (may Allah have mercy on him) pointed out that his mind would sometimes be lost. ممرور is a person who suffers from confusion (ikhtilat) because of some illness.”
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) described him as “Sahib al-manakir” (one who narrates rejected hadiths).
◈ He also says:
واه، ليس بشيئ “He is a weak narrator, good for nothing.”
Benefit:
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says about this narration:
لعله اختلقه السعدي
“Perhaps al-Sa’di (Ahmad ibn Hafs) fabricated this narration.”
But the only problem with this narrator is that of confusion (ikhtilat). Otherwise he is a “saduq” and “hasan al-hadith” narrator. He is not among those who lie deliberately.
➋ Concerning Sa’id ibn Uqba al-Kufi, Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
مجهول، غير ثقة “He is unknown and not reliable.”
——————
Narration number: ⓳
It is attributed to Sayyiduna Abdullah ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة الحكمة، وعلي بابها
“I am the city of wisdom and Ali is its door.”
Comment:
This is a false and fabricated narration, because:
➊ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says about it:
وهٰذا الحديث لا أعلم رواه أحد عن عيسي بن يونس غير عثمان بن عبد اللہ، وهٰذا الحديث فى الجملة معضل عن الـأعمش، ويروي عن أبي معاوية عن الـأعمش، ويرويه عن أبي معاوية أبو الصلت الهروي، وقد سرقه من أبي الصلت جماعة ضعفاء
“I do not know that anyone other than Uthman bin Abdullah narrated this hadith from Isa bin Yunus. In general, this narration is mu’dal (a chain in which several narrators are missing) from al-A’mash. Uthman also narrated it with the chain Abu Mu’awiyah from al-A’mash. From Abu Mu’awiyah, this narration is narrated by Abu al-Salt al-Harawi. Certainly, many weak narrators have stolen this narration from Abu al-Salt al-Harawi and narrated it.”
➋ Imam Ibn Hibban says about Uthman bin Khalid:
كان ممن يروي المقلوب عن الثقات، ويروي عن الـأثبات أسانيد ليس من رواياتهم، كأنه كان يقلب الـأسانيد، لا يحل الاحتجاج بخبره
“He narrates maqlub narrations from trustworthy narrators, and he narrates from trustworthy narrators chains that they never narrated, that is, he turns the chains upside down. It is not permissible to use his narration as evidence.”
But Imam al-Daraqutni says:
هٰذا وهم، لم يرو عثمان بن خالد عن عيسي بن يونس شيئا، وإنما روٰي هٰذا الحديث عن عيسي بن يونس عثمان بن عبد اللہ القرشي الشامي
“This is a mistake. Uthman bin Khalid did not narrate anything from Isa bin Yunus. This hadith was narrated from Isa bin Yunus by Uthman bin Abdullah al-Qurashi al-Shami.”
There are also two narrators named Uthman bin Abdullah: one al-Shami and the other al-Umawi. Imam al-Khatib al-Baghdadi (may Allah have mercy on him) and Hafiz Ibn al-Jawzi (may Allah have mercy on him) distinguished between the two, whereas the correct view is that both names belong to one and the same person, as Hafiz al-Iraqi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
فرق الخطيب وابن الجوزي بينه وبين عثمان بن عبد اللہ الـأموي، وكلاهما يروي عن مالك۔۔۔ وجمع الذهبي بينهما فى ترجمة واحدة
“al-Khatib al-Baghdadi and Ibn al-Jawzi distinguished between Uthman bin Abdullah al-Shami and Uthman bin Abdullah al-Umawi. Both narrate from Imam Malik, but Hafiz al-Dhahabi considered the two to be one and the same.”
Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) declared this decision of Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) to be correct.
Remember that this Uthman is a liar and a fabricator of hadiths.
➌ It also contains the tadlis of al-A’mash.
——————
Narration number: ⓴
One chain of the previous narration is as follows:
عن الحسن بن عثمان، عن محمود بن خداش، عن أبي معاوية
Comment:
This narration is also fabricated, because the narrator al-Hasan bin Uthman al-Tustari was a craftsman of false hadiths, as:
◈ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
كان عندي يضع، ويسرق حديث الناس
“In my view he used to fabricate hadiths and steal people’s hadiths.”
◈ Abdan al-Ahwazi (may Allah have mercy on him) declared him a liar.
——————
Narration number: 21
It is attributed to Abdullah bin Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة الحكمة، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم؛ فليأت الباب
“I am the city of wisdom and Ali is its gate, so whoever wants knowledge should come to the gate.”
Comment:
This is also a false narration, because:
➊ About the narrator Raja bin Salamah, Hafiz Ibn al-Jawzi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
اتهم بسرقة الحديث “He is accused of stealing hadith.”
➋ Abu Mu’awiyah Muhammad bin Hazim al-Darir is a mudallis (one who practises tadlis) narrator.
➌ It also contains the tadlis of the narrator al-A’mash.
➍ No biographical details could be found for the narrator Ahmad bin Muhammad bin Yazid bin Salim.
——————
Narration number: 22
It is narrated from Abdullah bin Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة الحكمة، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم؛ فليأت بابه
“I am the city of wisdom and Ali is its gate. Whoever wishes to acquire knowledge should come to the gate.”
Comment:
This is a false and fabricated narration, because:
➊ Its narrator Abu al-Salt Abd al-Salam bin Salih is “da’if (weak)” and “matruk (abandoned)”.
➋ It contains the tadlis of the narrator al-A’mash.
➌ Al-A’mash narrates this narration from Mujahid.
◈ Imam Yahya bin Sa’id al-Qattan (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
كتبت عن الـأعمش أحاديث عن مجاهد، كلها ملزقة، لم يسمعها
“I wrote down the narrations of al-A’mash from Mujahid. All of them are attributed to Imam Mujahid. Al-A’mash did not hear them from Mujahid.”
◈ Imam Yahya bin Ma’in (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
الـأعمش لم يسمع من مجاهد، وكل شيئ يرويه عنه؛ لم يسمع، إنما مرسلة مدلسة
“Al-A’mash has no hearing from Mujahid. Whatever narration al-A’mash narrated from Mujahid is mursal and mudallas.”
◈ Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
الـأعمش قليل السماع من مجاهد، وعامة ما يرويه عن مجاهد مدلس
“Al-A’mash’s hearing from Mujahid is next to nothing. Most of what he narrates from Mujahid is mudallas narrations.”
➍ Abu Mu’awiyah is also a “mudallis” and he is narrating with the word “‘an”.
Note: Some narrators have corroborated Abu al-Salt Abd al-Salam bin Salih in this narration. Please also look at their condition:
——————
Narration number: 23
Ibn Muhriz
has corroborated it and narrated the chain as follows:
عن محمد بن جعفر العلاف، قال : حدثنا محمد بن الطفيل، قال : حدثنا أبو معاوية عن الـأعمش، عن مجاهد
Comment:
This narration is also defective (mu’allal), because:
➊ A declaration of Ibn Muhriz’s trustworthiness is required.
➋ Muhammad bin al-Tufayl bin Malik al-Hanafi is mentioned only by Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) in al-Thiqat
. Therefore he is “majhul al-hal (of unknown condition)”.
——————
Narration number: 24
Muhammad bin Ja’far al-Faydi has corroborated it:
Comment:
In its chain of narration, the narrator Husayn ibn Fahm is not strong. Although Imam al-Hakim (may Allah have mercy on him) called him “trustworthy, reliable, a hafiz”, this is a leniency on the part of the Imam. He himself narrated from Imam al-Daraqutni (may Allah have mercy on him) that he said of him ليس بالقوي.
Moreover, in this chain there is also the problem of establishing the reliability of Abu al-Husayn Muhammad ibn Ahmad ibn Tamim al-Fitri.
——————
Narration number: 25
Imam Abu Ubayd al-Qasim ibn Sallam corroborated it in
.
Comment:
This chain is also false, for various reasons;
➊ Regarding Isma’il ibn Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Jubrini Abu Harun:
◈ Imam Ibn Abi Hatim (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
كتب إلى بجزئ، فنظرت فى حديثه، فلم أجد حديثه حديث أهل الصدق
“He wrote some hadiths and sent them to me. I looked at them, and I did not find among them a single hadith that matched the narration of truthful narrators.”
◈ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
يقلب الـأسانيد، ويسرق الحديث، لا يجوز الاحتجاج به
“He turns chains of narration upside down and steals hadiths. It is not permissible to use what he narrates as evidence.”
◈ Imam al-Hakim (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
روٰي عن سنيد وأبي عببد وعمرو بن أبي سلمة أحاديث موضوعة
“He narrates fabricated narrations, attributing them to Sunayd, Abu Ubayd and Amr ibn Salama.”
——————
Narration number: 26
Umar ibn Isma’il ibn Mujalid corroborated it in
.
Comment:
Regarding Umar ibn Isma’il:
◈ Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
ضعيف الحديث “What he narrates is weak.”
◈ Imam Ibn Ma’in (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
كذاب، يحدث أيضا بحديث أبي معاوية، عن الـأعمش، عن مجاهد، عن ابن عباس، عن النبى صلى اللہ عليه وسلم : ’أنا مدينة العلم، وعلي بابها‘، وهٰذا حديث كذب، ليس له أصل
“He is a liar narrator. He narrated this hadith with the chain: أبو معاوية، عن الـأعمش، عن مجاهد، عن ابن عباس، عن النبى صلى اللہ عليه وسلم: I am the city of knowledge and Ali is its door. This is a false narration. It has no basis.”
◈ Hafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) called him “matruk (abandoned)”.
——————
Narration number: 27
Ibrahim ibn Musa al-Razi corroborated it in
لأبي جعفر الطبري، ص: 105].
Comment:
Regarding this Ibrahim, Imam al-Tabari (may Allah have mercy on him) himself says:
هٰذا الشيخ لا أعرفه، ولا سمعت منه غير هٰذا الحديث
“I do not know this narrator, nor have I heard any narration from him other than this narration.”
——————
Narration number: 28
Ahmad ibn Salama, Abu Amr al-Jurjani corroborated it in
.
Comment:
This is also a false narration, because regarding Ahmad ibn Salama:
◈ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
حدث عن الثقات بالبواطيل، ويسرق الحديث
“He narrates false narrations, attributing them to trustworthy narrators, and steals hadiths.”
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) declared him a liar.
——————
Narration number: 29
Hasan ibn Rashid corroborated it in
.
Comment:
This chain is severely “da’if (weak)”, because its narrator Hasan ibn Ali al-Adawi is a liar.
◈ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
وهٰذا حديث أبي الصلت الهروي عن أبي معاوية، علٰي أنه قد حدث به غيره وسرق منه، من الضعفائ، وليس أحد ممن رواه عن أبي معاوية خير وأصدق من الحسن بن على ابن راشد
“This is the hadith of Abu al-Salt al-Harawi from Abu Mu’awiya. This hadith has also been narrated by weak narrators who stole it from Abu al-Salt. Among those who narrate from Abu Mu’awiya, there is none better and more truthful than Hasan ibn Ali ibn Rashid.”
——————
Narration number: 30
Musa ibn Muhammad al-Ansari corroborated it in
.
Comment:
This is also a false chain, because regarding its narrator Mahfuz ibn Bahr al-Antaki:
◈ Imam Abu Arubah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
كان محفوظ يكذب
“Mahfuz ibn Bahr used to narrate false narrations.”
Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) counted this narration among the false narrations of Mahfuz ibn Bahr.
◈ Ibn al-Ammi said:
من وضعه وأكاذيبه
“This is a narration he fabricated himself and one of his lies.”
——————
Narration number: 31
A man from the people of Sham (Syria) corroborated it in
.
Comment:
This is also an outright lie, because:
◈ Imam al-Daraqutni said:
إن أبا الصلت وضعه علٰي أبي معاوية، وسرقه منه جماعة، فحدثوا به عن أبي معاوية، منهم : عمر بن إسماعيل بن مجالد، ومحمد بن جعفر، ورجل كذاب من أهل الشام، حدث به عن هشام، عن أبي معاوية
“Abu al-Salt falsely attributed this narration to Abu Mu’awiya. A group of weak narrators stole it from him. Among them are Umar ibn Isma’il ibn Mujalid, Muhammad ibn Ja’far, and a lying man from the people of Sham. The Syrian liar narrated it with the chain: عن هشام، عن أبي معاوية.”
Imam al-Daraqutni (may Allah have mercy on him) did not mention its complete chain. However, he did declare the unnamed man a liar. That much is sufficient for its being false.
——————
Narration number: 32
Ja’far ibn Muhammad al-Baghdadi corroborated it in
.
Commentary:
This too is a false narration,
because regarding its narrator Ja’far ibn Muhammad al-Baghdadi:
◈ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
فيه جهالة
“This is an unknown narrator.”
And regarding this narration he says:
هٰذا موضوع “This is a fabricated narration.”
Regarding it Abu Ja’far Mutayyan (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
لم يرو هٰذا الحديث عن أبي معاوية من الثقات أحد، رواه أبو الصلت، فكذبوه
“None of the trustworthy narrators narrated this hadith from Abu Mu’awiyah. Only Abu al-Salt al-Harawi narrated it, whom the hadith scholars have declared a liar.”
In sum:
It is established that Abu al-Salt has no trustworthy corroborator, and the entire basis of this chain rests on Abu al-Salt, who is “matruk” (abandoned).
◈ Imam Ibn ‘Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
وهٰذا حديث أبي الصلت الهروي عن أبي معاوية، علٰي أنه قد حدث به غيره وسرق منه، من الضعفاء
“This is the hadith of Abu al-Salt al-Harawi from Abu Mu’awiyah. Several weak narrators have also narrated this hadith by stealing it from Abu al-Salt.”
——————
Narration No. 33
It is narrated from Anas ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said:
أنا مدينة العلم، وأبو بكر وعمر وعثمان سورها، وعلي بابها، فمن أراد العلم، فليأت الباب
“I am the city of knowledge; Abu Bakr, ‘Umar and ‘Uthman are its walls, and ‘Ali is its gate. So whoever intends to seek knowledge, let him come to the gate.”
Commentary:
This is a false (batil) narration, because:
➊ Its narrator Hasan ibn Tamim ibn Tamam is unknown, and his hearing from Anas (may Allah be pleased with him) also requires proof.
➋ The other narrator, Abu al-Qasim ‘Umar ibn Muhammad ibn Husayn al-Karkhi, also requires authentication.
Regarding this narration:
◈ Hafiz Ibn ‘Asakir (may Allah have mercy on him) says:
منكر جدا إسنادا ومتنا
“Both the chain and the text of this narration are extremely munkar (rejected).”
——————
Narration No. 34
This narration is also attributed to the Prophet ﷺ:
أنا مدينة العلم، وأبو بكر أساسها، وعمر حيطانها، وعثمان سقفها، وعلي بابها
“I am the city of knowledge; Abu Bakr is its foundation, ‘Umar its enclosing walls, ‘Uthman its roof, and ‘Ali is its gate.”
Commentary:
This is an outright lie. The one who fabricated it is Isma’il ibn ‘Ali ibn Muthanna al-Istarabadhi.
Opinions of the Imams of the Religion
Now consider the statements of the early imams about this narration:
➊ Imam Yahya ibn Ma’in (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
وهو حديث ليس له أصل “This hadith has no basis.”
Note:
It is also established from Imam Yahya ibn Ma’in (may Allah have mercy on him) that he called this hadith sahih (authentic).
↰ It may be that this judgment was earlier, and that his opinion changed after the true condition of a narrator became apparent.
➋ Imam Abu Zur’ah al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
وحديث أبي معاوية عن الـأعمش، عن مجاهد، عن ابن عباس : ’أنا مدينة الحكمة، وعلي بابها‘، كم من خلق قد افتضحوا فيه
“The hadith ‘I am the city of wisdom, and Ali is its door’, narrated from Abu Mu’awiyah through the chain from al-A’mash, from Mujahid, from Ibn Abbas: how many scholars have found fault with it.”
➌ Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi (may Allah have mercy on him) declared it “munkar” (rejected).
➍ Imam al-Tirmidhi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
هٰذا حديث غريب منكر “This hadith is gharib and munkar (rejected).”
➎ Imam Ibn Hibban (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
هٰذا خبر لا أصل له عن النبى صلى اللہ عليه وسلم “This narration is not established from the Prophet ﷺ.”
➑ Imam al-Daraqutni said:
الحديث مضطرب، غير ثابت “This hadith is mudtarib (inconsistent) and not established.”
➐ Imam al-Uqayli (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
ولا يصح فى هٰذا المتن حديث “No hadith with this meaning is authentic.”
➑ Imam Abu Ja’far Mutayyan (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
لم يرو هٰذا الحديث عن أبي معاوية من الثقات أحد، رواه أبو الصلت، فكذبوه “Not a single trustworthy narrator narrated this narration from Abu Mu’awiyah. Only Abu al-Salt al-Harawi narrated it, and the hadith scholars declared him a liar.”
➒ Imam Ibn Adi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
هٰذا حديث منكر موضوع “This hadith is munkar (rejected) and fabricated.”
➓ Hafiz Ibn Asakir (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
وكل هٰذه الروايات غير محفوظة “All the narrations of this meaning are munkar.”
⓫ Hafiz Ibn al-Jawzi declared it fabricated.
⓬ Hafiz al-Nawawi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
فحديث باطل “This is a false hadith.”
⓭ Hafiz al-Dhahabi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
والحديث موضوع، رواه الـأعمش “This hadith is fabricated; al-A’mash narrated it.”
⓮ Shaykh al-Islam Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah have mercy on him) also declared it fabricated.
⓯ Allamah Ibn Tahir (may Allah have mercy on him) also declared it fabricated.
⓰ Allamah Abd al-Rahman al-Mu’allimi (may Allah have mercy on him) also called it mawdu’ (fabricated).
Only Imam al-Hakim (may Allah have mercy on him) called it “sahih al-isnad (authentic in chain)”. Against the “da’if (weak) grading” of these majority of early and later imams, the authentication by Imam al-Hakim (may Allah have mercy on him) is not worth considering, because he was lenient. This is well known to the people of knowledge.
Some of the later scholars, for example Hafiz al-Ala’i
, Hafiz Ibn Hajar
, Hafiz al-Sakhawi
and Allamah al-Shawkani
, declared it “hasan (good)”, but this is not correct.
In sum:
This hadith, with all its chains of narration, is “da’if (weak) and munkar (rejected)”. All the routes of the hadith of Ibn Abbas are narrated through أبو معاوية عن الـأعمش، عن مجاهد, so it is also “da’if (weak) and mudallas”.
The virtue and merit of Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) are dear to us beyond measure, but it is absolutely not correct to treat narrations reported through false, “munkar” and “da’if” chains as virtues.
In the light of the authentic and established virtues and merits, the personality of Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is so clear that no need remains for such narrations, which the hadith scholars did not accept. May Allah grant us the ability to accept the truth. Amen!