´Ibn Juraij said:` 'Ata' informed me, from Habib bin Abi Thabit, from Ibn 'Umar -and he did not hear it from him- he said: 'Allah's Messenger said: "There is no 'Umra and no Ruqba. Whoever is given something on the basis of 'Umra or Ruqba, it belongs to him for the rest of his life and after he dies."' 'Ata' said: "It belongs to the other."
1؎ : In the next chain of narration, it is explicitly stated that Habib heard this hadith from Ibn ‘Umar radi Allahu anhuma. Ibn Hibban also says that Habib’s hearing from Ibn ‘Umar is established. Mizzi, in the biographies of both, does not mention the absence of hearing between them; in fact, if such a matter existed, he would certainly have mentioned it «ولم یسمع منہ».