Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah

It is narrated from Hazrat Sufyan, Hazrat Ibn Shubruma, and Hazrat Ibn Abi Layla that if a boat is taken on hire for the sea and then it sinks (breaks) and there is luggage in it, Hazrat Ibn Shubruma said: He will not be liable, Hazrat Ibn Abi Layla said: He will be liable, and Hazrat Sufyan said: We do not consider liability necessary upon him.