Narrated Umar ibn al-Khattab: Al-Aqra, the muadhdhin (announcer) of Umar ibn al-Khattab said: Umar sent me to a bishop and I called him. Umar said to him: Do you find me in the Book? He said: Yes. He asked: How do you find me? He said: I find you (like a) castle. Then he raised a whip to him, saying: What do you mean by castle? He replied: An iron castle and severely trustworthy. He asked: How do you find the one who will come after me? He said: I find him a pious caliph, except that he will prefer his relatives. Umar said: May Allah have mercy on Uthman: He said it three times. He then asked: How do you find the one who will come after him? He replied: I find him like rusty iron. Umar then put his hand on his head, and said: O filthy! O filthy! He said: Commander of the Faithful! He is a pious caliph, but when he is made caliph, the sword will be unsheathed and blood will be shed. Abu Dawud said: Al-dafr means filth or evil smell.
Hadith Referenceسنن ابي داود / كتاب السنة / 4656
Hadith Gradingالألبانی:ضعيف الإسناد | زبیر علی زئی:إسناده صحيح, الأقرع مؤذن عمر بن الخطاب: ثقة، وحماد بن سلمة سمع من الجريري قبل اختلاطه
Hadith Takhrij« تفرد بہ أبو داود، (تحفة الأشراف: 10408) (ضعیف الإسناد) » (عیسائی پادری کے قول کا کیا اعتبار؟)
Explanation & Benefits
Shaykh Umar Farooq Saeedi
Benefits and Issues: Among Muslims, such narrations from the People of the Book are neither explicitly affirmed nor denied; only the narration itself is permitted.
Source: Sunan Abu Dawood – Commentary by Shaykh Umar Farooq Saeedi, Page: 4656