Shaykh Umar Farooq Saeedi
1570. Commentary:
➊ The details of zakat on camels are according to the same principle that has already been mentioned in the previous hadith: “If they exceed one hundred and twenty, then (their shares should be divided) — for every fifty, one hiqqah, and for every forty, one bint labun, and the remainder is excused.”
➋ “Khalit” means partner, but some distinction has been made. Imam Malik says: When their wealth is distinct and separate from each other, then they are not considered khalit (but are partners), and when the shepherd, pasture, enclosure, and their male (breeding camel) are the same, then they are called khalit... In addition, it is also required that the amount of wealth of each one should also reach the nisab... Whereas Imam Shafi’i says that this is not necessary; rather, when the combined wealth reaches the nisab, they are considered khalit, even if one’s share is only a single goat.
➌ Combining wealth that is together or separating what is separate can be done for two purposes: to avoid zakat or to reduce its amount. For example, if sixty goats are separated, then there will be no zakat... Or, for two herds of fifty each, two goats would be due, but if they are combined, only one would be due, and thus one goat would be saved... This ruling applies to the owner, the shepherd, and the zakat collector alike, because it is possible that the collector may do this to benefit someone, or someone may devise a way to increase zakat; such actions are not permissible for anyone.
Source: Sunan Abu Dawood – Commentary by Shaykh Umar Farooq Saeedi, Page: 1570